From e00bcfe77ecd70f1bb06004367f05682911c84c1 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Vahid Ahmadi Date: Fri, 24 Jul 2026 16:20:19 +0100 Subject: [PATCH 1/3] Fix contradicted site claims and two undefined design tokens Content corrections, each verified against the repos: - frb-us page claimed "no stochastic simulation ... confidence bands are not available". stochsim_bands() has existed since us-frb-model #5 and is exported from frbus/__init__.py; the validation page already said the opposite, so the site contradicted itself. Split the row: mcontrol is still genuinely absent, and the honest limit is that the hosted MCP path returns a deterministic projection, not that the engine is missing. - frb-us page said "two invariants" and described a single cross-validated shock; VALIDATION.md gates four like-for-like scenarios. - svar page attributed 6,000 draws / 430 accepted / ESS 197.9 to the hosted forecast. Those belong to the Section-5 revision run; the hosted default is 2,000 draws, 135 accepted, ESS 65.3 -- the misattribution overstated posterior precision roughly threefold. - svar page said replication claims are "scored on the paper's original sample"; they are scored on the extended 1992Q1-2025Q1 window. - capabilities.py still described frb-us fidelity as "a reference shock". - oguk version in core.py was 0.3.0; OG-UK's pyproject.toml says 0.3.2. - 5.3e-12 -> 5.23e-12; and the "7-8 points" summary heading was left behind when #85 updated the body and table beneath it to 6-10. UI defects: - --brand-wash and --radius-card were referenced 5+ times but never defined, so those backgrounds resolved to nothing -- the PUBLISHED ANCHOR chips rendered as bare text while STATUTE/CALIBRATED rendered as pills, breaking the site's own three-class visual claim. - --brand and --brand-strong both resolve to --primary (a deliberate AA fix), which silently made .vc-s1 and .vc-s2 the same colour in every chart while .vc-lab/.vc-lab2 styled the legend as two colours. Series 2 now uses a dark slate that survives greyscale. - .vc-b2/.vc-b3 measured ~2.3:1 and ~1.3:1, under the WCAG 1.4.11 3:1 floor, on the comparison bars our numbers are judged against. - .vc-warn used the same teal as links and series 1, so "Weak" rendered in the affirmative accent; now --brand-warning. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) --- frb-us/index.html | 9 +++--- .../src/policyengine_macro/capabilities.py | 8 +++-- integration/src/policyengine_macro/core.py | 4 +-- style.css | 31 ++++++++++++++----- svar/index.html | 6 ++-- validation/index.html | 2 +- 6 files changed, 40 insertions(+), 20 deletions(-) diff --git a/frb-us/index.html b/frb-us/index.html index f869566..350a114 100644 --- a/frb-us/index.html +++ b/frb-us/index.html @@ -295,8 +295,9 @@

Machine precision on the baseline; the Fed's own noise floor on shocks.

This is a replication with a published anchor, and it is the sharpest-tested member of the suite — because for once the - ground truth is exact rather than statistical. Two invariants carry - the weight, and both are enforced in continuous integration. + ground truth is exact rather than statistical. Three invariants carry + the weight, and all are enforced in continuous integration — including + four like-for-like scenarios gated against vendor-generated references.

@@ -390,8 +391,8 @@

What is absent, and what is merely local.

The model-consistent-expectations (MCE) equation variants are not implemented — Frbus(path, mce=...) raises NotImplementedError. Anything that turns on agents anticipating announced future policy, forward guidance most obviously, is out of scope. - No mcontrol, no stochastic simulation - The reference implementation's targeting routine and its stochastic-simulation machinery are both out of scope, so confidence bands around a projection are not available here. + No mcontrol + The reference implementation's trajectory-targeting routine is out of scope. Stochastic simulation is implemented — stochsim_bands() produces seeded residual-bootstrap percentile bands — but the hosted frbus_shock path still returns a single deterministic projection, so bands are not available through the MCP surface. Hosted, but only as raw shocks diff --git a/integration/src/policyengine_macro/capabilities.py b/integration/src/policyengine_macro/capabilities.py index b5e9f33..dc096c9 100644 --- a/integration/src/policyengine_macro/capabilities.py +++ b/integration/src/policyengine_macro/capabilities.py @@ -219,9 +219,11 @@ def _quality(level: str, evidence: str, next_gate: str) -> dict: "frb-us": { "implementation_fidelity": _quality( "strong", - "The baseline and a reference shock match LONGBASE and pyfrbus at the " - "reference solver's numerical noise floor.", - "Extend like-for-like gates across official demos, closures and recodes.", + "The baseline and four like-for-like scenarios (monetary, fiscal " + "egfe, tax trp, non-inertial Taylor) match LONGBASE and pyfrbus at " + "the reference solver's numerical noise floor.", + "Extend like-for-like gates across further official demos, closures " + "and recodes; add the MCE expectations path.", ), "predictive_validation": _quality( "not_assessed", diff --git a/integration/src/policyengine_macro/core.py b/integration/src/policyengine_macro/core.py index d4888dd..c78ad2c 100644 --- a/integration/src/policyengine_macro/core.py +++ b/integration/src/policyengine_macro/core.py @@ -1766,7 +1766,7 @@ def _og_solve(solve_fn, **kwargs): failures are translated into clear messages: (a) no HuggingFace access to the dataset — set HUGGING_FACE_TOKEN; (b) policyengine-uk >= 2.89 renamed the dataset keys from enhanced_frs_2023_24_ to populace_uk_*, which - makes oguk 0.3.0 (pinning policyengine-uk==2.88.0) fail with a KeyError. + makes oguk 0.3.2 (pinning policyengine-uk==2.88.0) fail with a KeyError. """ try: return solve_fn(**kwargs) @@ -1777,7 +1777,7 @@ def _og_solve(solve_fn, **kwargs): "(a) no access to the enhanced-FRS dataset on HuggingFace — set " "HUGGING_FACE_TOKEN to a token with access " "(policyengine.tax_benefit_models.uk.ensure_datasets downloads " - "it); (b) incompatible policyengine-uk version — oguk 0.3.0 " + "it); (b) incompatible policyengine-uk version — oguk 0.3.2 " "requires policyengine-uk==2.88.0 (>= 2.89 renamed the datasets)" ": pip install 'policyengine-uk==2.88.0'." ) from e diff --git a/style.css b/style.css index 0bc8c20..744ae9e 100644 --- a/style.css +++ b/style.css @@ -24,6 +24,12 @@ that --brand and --brand-strong resolve to the same AA-passing value. #285E61 = teal-700, 7.33:1 on white. */ --brand-deep: #285E61; + /* Chart series 2. --brand-strong collapsed onto --primary for AA, which + left .vc-s1 and .vc-s2 the same colour, distinguished only by a dash + pattern -- while .vc-lab/.vc-lab2 styled the legend as two colours. + A dark slate keeps the two-series-plus-neutrals restraint and reads + apart from teal in greyscale. 10.4:1 on white. */ + --chart-s2: #334155; /* AA-safe warning text. --text-warning (#c2410c) is only 4.10:1 against the 16%-tinted chip .tag-local paints behind it; #9A3412 is 5.63:1 there. */ --brand-warning: #9A3412; @@ -86,6 +92,12 @@ Cards, code blocks, charts and panels used 2px/3px/6px/8px in different places for the same job. One value now. */ --radius: 8px; + /* Referenced by .section-tabs, the model navs, .contact-email, + .comparison-table row hover and .verification-tag, but never defined -- + so those backgrounds resolved to nothing and the PUBLISHED ANCHOR chips + rendered as bare text while STATUTE/CALIBRATED rendered as pills. */ + --brand-wash: color-mix(in srgb, var(--primary) 8%, transparent); + --radius-card: var(--radius); --radius-sm: 4px; } @@ -1068,8 +1080,8 @@ h2 { } .vchart text { font-family: var(--mono); fill: var(--paper-dim); } .vchart .vc-tick { font-size: 11px; } -.vchart .vc-lab { font-size: 12px; fill: var(--paper); } -.vchart .vc-lab2 { fill: var(--brand-strong); } +.vchart .vc-lab { font-size: 12px; fill: var(--brand); } +.vchart .vc-lab2 { fill: var(--chart-s2); } .vchart .vc-rowlab { font-size: 11.5px; fill: var(--paper-dim); } .vchart .vc-val { font-size: 12px; fill: var(--paper); font-weight: 600; } .vchart .vc-note { font-size: 10.5px; fill: var(--paper-faint); } @@ -1079,11 +1091,14 @@ h2 { /* series 1 = ours, series 2 = the official/published counterpart */ .vchart .vc-s1 { fill: none; stroke: var(--brand); stroke-width: 2; stroke-linejoin: round; } .vchart .vc-s1-dot { fill: var(--brand); } -.vchart .vc-s2 { fill: none; stroke: var(--brand-strong); stroke-width: 2; stroke-dasharray: 5 4; stroke-linejoin: round; } -.vchart .vc-s2-dot { fill: var(--brand-strong); } +.vchart .vc-s2 { fill: none; stroke: var(--chart-s2); stroke-width: 2; stroke-dasharray: 5 4; stroke-linejoin: round; } +.vchart .vc-s2-dot { fill: var(--chart-s2); } .vchart .vc-b1 { fill: var(--brand); } -.vchart .vc-b2 { fill: color-mix(in srgb, var(--paper) 34%, transparent); } -.vchart .vc-b3 { fill: color-mix(in srgb, var(--paper) 18%, transparent); } +/* 34%/18% measured ~2.3:1 and ~1.3:1 on the chart surface, under the 3:1 + WCAG 1.4.11 floor -- and these are the official/comparison bars our numbers + are judged against. */ +.vchart .vc-b2 { fill: color-mix(in srgb, var(--paper) 55%, transparent); } +.vchart .vc-b3 { fill: color-mix(in srgb, var(--paper) 35%, transparent); } .vchart .vc-band90 { fill: color-mix(in srgb, var(--brand) 13%, transparent); } .vchart .vc-band68 { fill: color-mix(in srgb, var(--brand) 26%, transparent); } .current-outlook { margin: 28px 0 8px; } @@ -1483,4 +1498,6 @@ h2 { @media (max-width: 1000px) { .hf-tick.hf-q { display: initial; } } /* honest-warning cells in validation tables (over-band, imposed, targeted) */ -.vchart .vc-warn, td.vc-warn, th.vc-warn { color: var(--brand-strong); font-weight: 600; } +/* Was --brand-strong: the same teal as links, series 1 and .metric-val, so + "Weak" read in the site's affirmative accent. --brand-warning is AA-tested. */ +.vchart .vc-warn, td.vc-warn, th.vc-warn { color: var(--brand-warning); font-weight: 600; } diff --git a/svar/index.html b/svar/index.html index 42b2807..15bff9d 100644 --- a/svar/index.html +++ b/svar/index.html @@ -177,7 +177,7 @@

Eight variables, six named shocks.

importance-weighted effective sample size of 355.9 — so medians and bands are correct but noisier than the paper's. The hosted forecast conditions on the current vintage — data through - 2026Q1 — with 6,000 draws (430 accepted, ESS 197.9), while retaining + 2026Q1 — with a 2,000-draw default (135 accepted, ESS 65.3), while retaining the 2025Q1 coefficient-estimation endpoint.

@@ -316,7 +316,7 @@

Replicates the paper; beat by outturn on its own frozen forecast.

Forecast-revision adding-up identity - exact per draw (max abs error 5.3e-12) + exact per draw (max abs error 5.23e-12) holds by construction @@ -368,7 +368,7 @@

Where this departs from the Bank's model.

Frozen data edge - Coefficient estimation to 2025Q1; conditioning data to 2026Q1 (refreshed July 2026). Results shift with data revisions; the replication claims are scored on the paper's original sample. + Coefficient estimation to 2025Q1; conditioning data to 2026Q1 (refreshed July 2026). Results shift with data revisions. The replication claims are scored on the extended 1992Q1–2025Q1 sample, not the paper's original 1992Q1–2023Q2 window. Proxied world aggregates diff --git a/validation/index.html b/validation/index.html index 3ac11ae..d102bb9 100644 --- a/validation/index.html +++ b/validation/index.html @@ -513,7 +513,7 @@

Against a Bank of England paper, and against outturns.

Global shocks = world demand + energy + supply. Ours = 10,000-draw production run; paper values approximate. Global-shock FEVD shares at the one-year horizon: the production run against the paper's published values. Source: papers/boe-svar/figures/comparison_numbers.json and the paper's validation table.
- Why the fast CI configuration lands 7–8 points off + Why the fast CI configuration lands 6–10 points off

The deliberately cheap unweighted CI configuration lands at 49.6% and 43.8% — 6–10 points off, in opposite directions for the two From 2f92c2ffe6c2badb8acb9e8a8d5ad10365096a91 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Vahid Ahmadi Date: Fri, 24 Jul 2026 16:30:45 +0100 Subject: [PATCH 2/3] Correct the GDP claim: indistinguishable from a random walk, not beaten Adding Diebold-Mariano tests to boe-var-model's rolling evaluation shows only 3 of 64 (variable, horizon) cells differ significantly from the benchmark at 5%. The site said "CPI beats no change; GDP does not in rolling tests", which reads as an established loss. It is not: UK GDP's ratio of 1.06-1.09 carries p = 0.38 to 0.67, so the model is statistically indistinguishable from a random walk for GDP rather than worse than it. The CPI win survives at short horizons (0.63, p < 0.005 at h=1) but not at h=8 (p = 0.11). The one significant adverse result is the exchange rate at h=8 (1.41, p = 0.03). Updates the audit cell, the chart description and the capabilities registry, and syncs the regenerated artifact carrying dm_stat, dm_pvalue and per-origin errors. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) --- .../src/policyengine_macro/capabilities.py | 15 +- .../boe-svar/figures/rolling_evaluation.json | 6783 ++++++++++++++++- validation/index.html | 4 +- 3 files changed, 6794 insertions(+), 8 deletions(-) diff --git a/integration/src/policyengine_macro/capabilities.py b/integration/src/policyengine_macro/capabilities.py index dc096c9..e1276f2 100644 --- a/integration/src/policyengine_macro/capabilities.py +++ b/integration/src/policyengine_macro/capabilities.py @@ -184,11 +184,16 @@ def _quality(level: str, evidence: str, next_gate: str) -> dict: ), "predictive_validation": _quality( "moderate", - "Across 49 leakage-safe rolling origins, CPI beats no change at one- " - "and eight-quarter horizons, while GDP is about 6% worse; the separate " - "seven-quarter frozen-edge evaluation gives 0.32pp RMSE.", - "Compare with a declared BVAR benchmark and publish proper predictive " - "scores across the rolling origins.", + "Across 49 leakage-safe rolling origins, only 3 of 64 (variable, " + "horizon) cells differ significantly from a random walk by a " + "Diebold-Mariano test. UK CPI is significantly better at short " + "horizons (ratio 0.63, p<0.005 at h=1); UK GDP's higher ratio " + "(1.06-1.09) is NOT significant at any horizon (p=0.38-0.67), so " + "it is indistinguishable from the benchmark rather than beaten by " + "it. The exchange rate is significantly worse at h=8 (1.41, " + "p=0.03). The frozen-edge evaluation gives 0.32pp RMSE.", + "Add a declared BVAR benchmark, score the predictive densities " + "(not just point forecasts), and report interval coverage.", ), "identification_robustness": _quality( "moderate", diff --git a/papers/boe-svar/figures/rolling_evaluation.json b/papers/boe-svar/figures/rolling_evaluation.json index 4b8dace..e8b1a5b 100644 --- a/papers/boe-svar/figures/rolling_evaluation.json +++ b/papers/boe-svar/figures/rolling_evaluation.json @@ -1,5 +1,56 @@ { "method": "expanding-window pseudo-out-of-sample evaluation", + "origin_index": [ + 80, + 81, + 82, + 83, + 84, + 85, + 86, + 87, + 88, + 89, + 90, + 91, + 92, + 93, + 94, + 95, + 96, + 97, + 98, + 99, + 100, + 101, + 102, + 103, + 104, + 105, + 106, + 107, + 108, + 109, + 110, + 111, + 112, + 113, + 114, + 115, + 116, + 117, + 118, + 119, + 120, + 121, + 122, + 123, + 124, + 125, + 126, + 127, + 128 + ], "lags": 4, "origins": 49, "first_origin": 80, @@ -8,6 +59,7 @@ { "horizon": 1, "variables_beating_random_walk": 4, + "n_origins": 49, "relative_rmse_by_variable": { "world_gdp": 1.0449602705974248, "world_cpi": 0.7328656942968828, @@ -37,11 +89,852 @@ "cpisa": 1.0279533978722588, "cpi_energy": 5.22803238780597, "uk_gdp": 4.0721158021768025 + }, + "dm_stat_by_variable": { + "world_gdp": 0.582575469189247, + "world_cpi": -3.3602046102849155, + "oil_price": 0.8552333408207591, + "bank_rate": -1.4939078211926613, + "eri": 0.941662008935355, + "cpisa": -3.300553825440106, + "cpi_energy": -0.4507891636365008, + "uk_gdp": 0.8791281401499687 + }, + "dm_pvalue_by_variable": { + "world_gdp": 0.5629059685355942, + "world_cpi": 0.0015342036182246805, + "oil_price": 0.3966708506861968, + "bank_rate": 0.1417448221368488, + "eri": 0.3510810214678084, + "cpisa": 0.0018251499178248238, + "cpi_energy": 0.6541713412599799, + "uk_gdp": 0.3837117600524136 + }, + "bvar_errors_by_origin": { + "world_gdp": [ + 0.4727662299528106, + 0.3104611193452911, + 0.5485470407870139, + 0.07256626851437886, + -0.4041871307054521, + -0.1482326310469375, + -0.0006363486239138183, + 0.06788851481371694, + -0.0442371505095025, + -0.19366699424961098, + 0.038362765733268134, + -0.3915827276163668, + 0.07448940357852507, + 0.18653809505650543, + 0.11725714167948809, + -0.004509162652766463, + 0.27945378752195893, + 0.046828130109020094, + -0.2800466814652509, + -0.20273207767939994, + -0.08239654694619958, + -0.19108114434789059, + -0.29558963330686083, + 0.34863749217964823, + -0.06736073739517678, + 0.22781211764385034, + -0.03655255761140097, + -0.2935933912615951, + -0.0041253354095260875, + 0.05859240622936568, + 0.44969093888431644, + 2.8295811343112405, + 9.55561055272642, + -10.600068637215315, + -0.8544942773469302, + -0.6470514883981195, + -1.4086433200533293, + -1.2163347366951598, + -0.6580098272455075, + -0.15560009974262812, + -0.34610712982760106, + -0.3596234225510102, + 0.006482967644501514, + 0.027680089759599014, + -0.13792140833828626, + -0.05514586875887062, + 0.11066401153112793, + -0.0435792045837502, + -0.16132097022176595 + ], + "world_cpi": [ + -0.33497926142428014, + 0.4848941757413172, + -0.20834857425018072, + 0.37491942151694957, + -0.000552323205738503, + 0.44097381790891177, + 0.1564148819297202, + 0.46432363327494386, + -0.20171260410131708, + 0.6418099710794536, + 0.41852486087708485, + 1.005401034798581, + -0.8758301302128757, + 0.5280628053339456, + 0.36153170789009437, + 0.8902142946240588, + -0.766378215121108, + 0.3214755409070449, + -0.05819234361609915, + 0.21839203890209546, + -0.38718507771142185, + 0.28158692019292175, + -0.11685874636225435, + 0.207127057589787, + -0.7699480865409214, + -0.02442396970906202, + 0.12781911353380337, + 0.645419668351451, + -0.8828086679136504, + 0.26237267163293154, + -0.10998501741380551, + 0.45149201745363143, + 0.08672602998456114, + 0.01016201995952315, + 0.29298958674621645, + -0.4999648455228112, + -0.9555346476725504, + -0.3432552976773309, + -1.2392699314059996, + -1.4921419302147, + -2.104999776385398, + -0.5123162899870977, + -0.8948430941238144, + 0.4243350372183272, + -0.5103490616330646, + 0.09032848634842594, + 0.3168097638574068, + 0.08076790120156829, + -0.5820685862428263 + ], + "oil_price": [ + 13.323887817174523, + 3.2302034903588606, + 6.87318762392681, + -2.5365315383435814, + 10.791476947798856, + -0.9830727315076615, + 9.755511633051697, + 7.3614113362799, + 2.877346100205159, + 10.825730654797894, + 27.393648459108306, + 31.74472881478391, + -11.098859764914039, + 27.055474121805105, + 12.95715162574379, + 18.502323633585945, + -27.15448913668098, + -3.096031119513725, + -9.437637937501734, + -2.1724350677715734, + 13.397619461759348, + 1.7973656702939707, + -12.340217829189385, + -1.3076470424971944, + -12.451277562759458, + -3.031212367590456, + 10.642986934690327, + 8.155887797763114, + -7.240405403403599, + 7.907644366639204, + 4.362638363593192, + 19.873720111949297, + 35.834318134553484, + -28.814361496049457, + 1.135674341275319, + -22.395259516352155, + -7.459774394415092, + -5.182175013856863, + -8.643538192865265, + -19.42378197780306, + -17.162749060778594, + 9.772507756387938, + 8.97208116995671, + 6.1418695240690795, + 3.5970580680404964, + -14.430257274596954, + -2.0687169917173946, + 0.7272417984235062, + -7.34872701723782 + ], + "bank_rate": [ + 0.0019126614730542446, + -0.022653007052794882, + -0.005114623523681805, + -0.0860569582054092, + -0.12880288303984178, + -0.012119219126675851, + 0.034286955739936786, + 0.05223175705730099, + 0.04733781672812354, + 0.08736612177292946, + 0.049967061726866824, + -0.02294833370506899, + -0.006166253514838238, + 0.12966476642412195, + 0.018763544856895797, + -0.005073122546503939, + -0.08886241672530787, + 0.2358350263449434, + 0.007548613850964558, + -0.00502470687634099, + 0.06217418387885354, + 0.07937985461627634, + -0.13092982263820208, + 0.022869529958827073, + 0.018437408133088473, + -0.12003855178882561, + -0.11668818347964871, + -0.05144767878864831, + -0.02789703703709967, + 0.03777051590931291, + -0.06665509000140912, + 0.11771269101677306, + 0.11645696920598689, + -0.5520134430068132, + 0.09828772364146435, + 0.07232076195374817, + 0.15859910425471044, + 0.14455726708262887, + 0.014875636700057107, + -0.3023650124312417, + -0.4111700949397207, + -0.5363256117761881, + -1.1317351636775104, + -0.8128024180786477, + -0.4409293501849598, + -0.5154759396902016, + 0.057339274195184586, + -0.041866091993880694, + -0.02776918691050856 + ], + "eri": [ + -2.6360728399881737, + -1.0975716357696115, + 0.794581339936542, + 3.750426371006199, + -0.8712627739737968, + -0.8727194263988736, + -2.7236873383466786, + -2.0504128768444048, + -1.0843923653878278, + -0.5951293698533959, + 1.5138588433948144, + -1.681454887876555, + -0.6715386493900155, + -0.7017336244430226, + 1.7822960157104717, + 6.869857552102701, + 2.2614910522687524, + 8.725585793381356, + 2.331366883030114, + -1.0503932836584227, + -1.203729819513569, + 1.9650617106955224, + -1.5843389482971588, + -1.6519870358088156, + -0.20497844883766447, + 1.4035438557300495, + -0.5466302963038174, + -1.6249312475825377, + 0.6589752750288085, + 3.056222823086898, + -5.183931636976638, + 0.26629497478029407, + 1.2929050284070058, + -1.1471326139302391, + -0.08981352449518454, + -2.8433746225080654, + -1.3908360049130692, + 0.1209306965335486, + 0.08475191035472562, + -1.4178803130803317, + 2.2078854848846845, + 0.9507274910666865, + -1.4155526469608617, + -1.559514851660822, + -3.8057195902877083, + -2.577863065240706, + 1.1195952746859916, + -2.2082610329625254, + -0.6794301598895913 + ], + "cpisa": [ + 0.6960835178616094, + 0.14303168064992633, + -0.5117636942615604, + -0.09021905857565571, + 0.77361357350253, + 0.06989217236849754, + 0.13957830671608917, + 0.13524400673730952, + 0.6665025570204648, + 0.3078967426072836, + 0.5676172396766219, + 0.7773920197117263, + 0.5227707846817111, + 0.09656616061192835, + 0.3087938823746299, + 0.3845141028318153, + 0.44709499303775146, + -0.30611753415274734, + -0.09263758459400151, + -0.4011724892878874, + 0.10672313968080971, + -0.33318548658075997, + -0.306930209819825, + -0.08152066078008602, + 0.38074585837557606, + -0.3079620229070201, + 0.04783167934175481, + 0.30768307974545905, + 0.09500614189698808, + -0.13845404829481822, + 0.4052563159073088, + -0.017685723841282197, + 1.0513810770077043, + -0.5549484717402606, + 0.30971041173933145, + -0.18052420501601318, + -0.195800009627078, + -0.8011563669318775, + -1.5251422409627367, + -0.9316545198585686, + -2.5098612439185786, + -0.652834314670315, + -1.5776779502833165, + 0.10378488175865641, + -0.9637151081248589, + 0.4119105494161204, + 0.3361083051369178, + -0.07795757573529727, + 0.1577276279727471 + ], + "cpi_energy": [ + 2.5927019145774466, + 2.7083635251673286, + 0.2130858652817551, + -0.7838212678425407, + 2.467670312821042, + 1.0870182815710905, + 2.581969424434078, + 0.3753256701868395, + 1.9344511439736607, + 1.7885894852516913, + 4.379951507585815, + 6.692081250850947, + -1.9058469665242228, + 2.6943423050472575, + 3.501401017489002, + 3.167215207010031, + -2.8221970576689728, + -0.41232382710325055, + -1.1312368680368081, + -1.0098331461017551, + 1.1494548568633718, + 0.18096193967426188, + -1.4987488024568165, + 0.29774980559136566, + -1.7453225234112324, + -2.0770217537062763, + -0.13940537928124286, + 6.457600933353319, + -6.760586591801257, + 1.3596484519729302, + 3.7998184040237675, + 1.3820876935451452, + 7.242184461910142, + -4.498154757192083, + 3.7278391918938496, + -2.8674353150829575, + -5.955003374157627, + -1.3304937387345035, + -7.988567374654622, + -1.376054078944776, + -24.466207548793705, + 3.7384663614229794, + -4.01547199730328, + 7.533250094183472, + 4.866875560979111, + 8.811005129450564, + 2.859501380324673, + -0.27659139460160986, + 4.841388315049244 + ], + "uk_gdp": [ + 0.3258822339246308, + -0.8180772712591988, + 0.5088904677061237, + -0.11361066697304523, + -0.5376550752610001, + -0.4277062260191542, + -0.25069649989291065, + -0.35722990027693413, + -0.4658108496150817, + -0.25096502839505774, + -0.08547213961173838, + 0.27445245364469883, + 0.23179161650068636, + 0.3053847953785862, + 0.016297120171657298, + 0.15863885181465776, + -0.09146005957791203, + 0.24228942745799031, + -0.13293667231414474, + -0.4237674167532077, + -0.2512197716371247, + -0.030239564433031774, + -0.1333622342358467, + 0.5672655603061685, + 0.2713657093393067, + 0.14906783267815626, + 0.23029422618606077, + -0.14816051575940037, + 0.3088862122228875, + -0.10938125553320788, + 0.3923197480273757, + 3.206818822758578, + 21.992210803144417, + -19.13930603321296, + -2.281804101590751, + 1.2241593324645237, + -6.455869528956555, + -1.7546413620252679, + -1.3897295789731743, + -0.9650520447155486, + -0.28529671343585505, + -0.11200299875213204, + -0.27885963739231556, + -0.10732837507089243, + -0.046814709433647295, + 0.27590892211605933, + 0.43698081688057755, + -0.7471672922063135, + -0.657716442483661 + ] + }, + "random_walk_errors_by_origin": { + "world_gdp": [ + -0.030716000000040822, + -0.11933399999998073, + 0.06985900000000811, + -0.24736999999998943, + -0.6911860000000161, + -0.5864460000000236, + -0.5084489999999846, + -0.45034499999997024, + -0.5695270000000505, + -0.7640169999999671, + -0.5396120000000337, + -0.9301999999999566, + -0.5704210000000103, + -0.5270009999999843, + -0.5114770000000135, + -0.644802000000027, + -0.34049199999998336, + -0.6417149999999765, + -0.8084610000000225, + -0.7957160000000272, + -0.73545299999995, + -0.8566880000000197, + -0.9417129999999929, + -0.36068800000003876, + -0.6328999999999496, + -0.337929000000031, + -0.5155530000000113, + -0.7560029999999642, + -0.5607980000000339, + -0.5063529999999901, + -0.0498450000000048, + 2.333845999999994, + 9.622070000000008, + -9.012761000000012, + -0.687656000000004, + -1.0755069999999591, + -1.9885730000000308, + -1.4782829999999763, + -0.9603490000000079, + -0.4654130000000123, + -0.7433560000000057, + -0.5954160000000002, + -0.25946299999998246, + -0.22630900000001475, + -0.4054140000000075, + -0.3441249999999627, + -0.23154400000004216, + -0.28695399999998017, + -0.3709129999999732 + ], + "world_cpi": [ + -0.8812060000000201, + -0.02768300000002455, + -0.7532329999999661, + -0.14078000000000657, + -0.523381000000029, + -0.07312199999995528, + -0.3777870000000121, + -0.026028999999994085, + -0.6679190000000403, + 0.15657300000003715, + -0.04373800000001893, + 0.6056800000000067, + -1.1574729999999818, + 0.1266650000000027, + 0.01952699999998231, + 0.5488409999999817, + -1.0733089999999947, + -0.07743399999998246, + -0.4943380000000275, + -0.20129599999995662, + -0.7921489999999949, + -0.07289300000002186, + -0.5121869999999831, + -0.1908510000000092, + -1.1123440000000073, + -0.38027099999999336, + -0.2706320000000346, + 0.2973570000000336, + -1.2415730000000167, + -0.08425799999997707, + -0.5095010000000002, + 0.1414429999999811, + -0.05828700000000708, + -0.02544199999999819, + -0.14718499999997903, + -0.8485750000000394, + -1.3190069999999992, + -0.7269929999999931, + -1.6769180000000006, + -1.988867999999968, + -2.721180000000004, + -1.4726709999999912, + -1.737273000000016, + -0.4877630000000295, + -1.1525570000000016, + -0.5988209999999867, + -0.2710379999999759, + -0.4297770000000014, + -1.092025000000035 + ], + "oil_price": [ + 9.102246000000036, + -0.6305270000000291, + 2.5708329999999933, + -4.742305999999985, + 8.014227000000005, + -5.137755000000027, + 5.45993500000003, + 4.073770999999965, + 0.013620000000003074, + 6.558956000000023, + 23.960323000000017, + 29.109256999999957, + -12.463707, + 22.164408000000037, + 12.007162999999991, + 16.819128999999975, + -28.768054000000006, + -8.149988999999948, + -13.385557000000006, + -6.213435000000004, + 10.935568999999987, + 0.5812599999999861, + -14.129085999999973, + -3.39887200000004, + -13.05262399999998, + -4.932042000000024, + 10.001672000000042, + 8.379580999999973, + -7.995704999999987, + 6.146872999999971, + 3.70845700000001, + 19.944637999999998, + 39.13122100000004, + -21.75561700000003, + -1.9996449999999868, + -24.976788999999997, + -10.189127999999982, + -5.892306000000019, + -8.628895, + -18.69259599999998, + -17.159785, + 9.356764999999996, + 12.280583999999976, + 12.210865000000013, + 10.175313000000017, + -8.009723000000008, + 2.018301000000008, + 4.004754999999989, + -3.655257000000006 + ], + "bank_rate": [ + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.1577, + 0.0923, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + -0.1587, + -0.09129999999999999, + 0.0, + -0.1602, + -0.08979999999999999, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.13829999999999998, + 0.5117, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + -0.02339999999999999, + -0.3329, + -0.502, + -0.6588999999999999, + -1.1884000000000001, + -1.0499, + -0.6028000000000002, + -0.7018999999999993, + -0.08980000000000032, + 0.0, + 0.0 + ], + "eri": [ + -2.4120080000000144, + -1.107670999999982, + 0.5414199999999596, + 4.030928000000017, + -0.2427240000000097, + -0.8837110000000052, + -2.812494999999956, + -2.3800710000000436, + -1.547758999999985, + -1.2641729999999711, + 0.8242750000000001, + -2.3762179999999944, + -1.9857730000000515, + -1.8148179999999456, + 0.764430999999945, + 5.787853000000041, + 1.6827989999999886, + 8.155073000000016, + 2.902153999999996, + -0.635325000000023, + -1.1618439999999737, + 1.7956009999999765, + -1.4789589999999748, + -1.6842060000000174, + -0.09538200000002917, + 1.638492000000042, + 0.025322999999957574, + -1.2223229999999603, + 0.469222000000002, + 3.3835770000000025, + -4.690906000000041, + 0.22164800000001605, + 2.3314869999999814, + -0.06806399999999257, + -0.6031820000000039, + -3.194723999999951, + -1.64905600000003, + 0.020541999999977634, + 0.18201100000004544, + -0.8850230000000465, + 2.6694400000000087, + 2.5632310000000302, + 0.08551099999999678, + -0.11749500000001944, + -2.863442999999961, + -2.17001300000004, + 1.2347809999999981, + -1.676074999999969, + -0.4611760000000231 + ], + "cpisa": [ + -0.09483499999998912, + -0.5765220000000113, + -1.2020239999999944, + -0.8598800000000324, + -0.005504999999971005, + -0.6368459999999914, + -0.5666909999999916, + -0.5501370000000065, + 0.006904999999960637, + -0.33184599999998454, + -0.027183999999977004, + 0.2515720000000101, + 0.14076299999999264, + -0.39843400000000884, + -0.09365200000002005, + 0.01687400000002981, + 0.14265399999999318, + -0.76228100000003, + -0.5865569999999707, + -0.9408839999999827, + -0.42863700000003746, + -0.8141819999999598, + -0.7929000000000315, + -0.640564999999981, + -0.14672100000001365, + -0.8961310000000253, + -0.5546589999999583, + -0.23104000000000724, + -0.3169880000000376, + -0.730515999999966, + -0.11445100000003094, + -0.48021999999997433, + 0.6472190000000069, + -0.6664240000000063, + -0.08295299999997496, + -0.5411280000000147, + -0.7162519999999972, + -1.3764050000000339, + -2.1403909999999655, + -1.7809060000000159, + -3.4586080000000265, + -2.1565269999999828, + -2.816059999999993, + -1.2617500000000064, + -1.8674719999999638, + -0.5525510000000509, + -0.39095499999996264, + -0.6765550000000076, + -0.46885300000002417 + ], + "cpi_energy": [ + 0.32212700000002314, + 0.7876309999999194, + -1.5503019999999879, + -2.552498000000014, + 0.6044370000000754, + -0.6378600000000461, + 0.7552590000000237, + -1.181993000000034, + 0.44419600000003356, + 0.2482239999999365, + 3.076818000000003, + 5.956113000000073, + -1.7893490000000156, + 1.5859209999999848, + 3.192933000000039, + 3.0774940000000015, + -2.5207550000000083, + -1.3763740000000553, + -2.0393530000000055, + -2.183080000000018, + 0.05761700000005021, + -0.5201510000000553, + -2.252051999999935, + -0.8583840000000009, + -2.533143999999993, + -3.256614000000013, + -1.306284000000005, + 5.643371999999999, + -7.020559000000048, + 0.14459199999998873, + 2.989573000000064, + 0.891648000000032, + 7.72724699999992, + -2.130457999999976, + 3.0851959999999963, + -3.14100499999995, + -6.986261000000013, + -2.4625919999999724, + -9.14979100000005, + -3.3917940000000044, + -26.727036, + -1.9263349999999946, + -7.604506000000015, + 3.8293479999999818, + 3.258762000000047, + 7.580307999999945, + 2.5737400000000434, + -0.024446000000011736, + 4.946910000000003 + ], + "uk_gdp": [ + 0.053030000000035216, + -1.0309400000001006, + 0.14447900000004665, + -0.26494800000000396, + -0.6629129999998895, + -0.7631810000000314, + -0.6572739999999158, + -0.7978840000000673, + -0.9364490000000387, + -0.8107370000000174, + -0.6577330000000075, + -0.3031949999999597, + -0.455511000000115, + -0.38699099999985265, + -0.5974710000000414, + -0.502140000000054, + -0.7328709999999319, + -0.440511000000015, + -0.617085999999972, + -0.9494509999999536, + -0.8495040000000245, + -0.6744760000001406, + -0.7477389999999104, + -0.07848199999989447, + -0.21732600000018465, + -0.31656299999986004, + -0.12966800000003786, + -0.502570999999989, + -0.2130099999999402, + -0.549118000000135, + -0.005965000000060172, + 2.7832850000002054, + 22.197124999999915, + -15.670178000000078, + -1.3587119999999686, + 1.0819960000001174, + -6.749305000000049, + -1.6725800000001527, + -1.368244999999888, + -1.0082500000000891, + -0.5563760000000002, + -0.10106499999983498, + -0.25991300000009687, + -0.05645800000002055, + -0.04134299999986979, + 0.23988399999984722, + 0.32195900000010624, + -0.7254530000000159, + -0.6192599999999402 + ] } }, { "horizon": 2, "variables_beating_random_walk": 4, + "n_origins": 49, "relative_rmse_by_variable": { "world_gdp": 1.0265405808866364, "world_cpi": 0.6832761881547914, @@ -71,11 +964,852 @@ "cpisa": 1.9547477893535623, "cpi_energy": 8.166628807516847, "uk_gdp": 4.795663574998965 + }, + "dm_stat_by_variable": { + "world_gdp": 0.30161343092960485, + "world_cpi": -2.797651787869937, + "oil_price": 1.0575367360271761, + "bank_rate": -0.9191413293654591, + "eri": 1.5872418865611142, + "cpisa": -2.5483966141461605, + "cpi_energy": -0.3027880336747207, + "uk_gdp": 0.974067032765042 + }, + "dm_pvalue_by_variable": { + "world_gdp": 0.7642496543725235, + "world_cpi": 0.007386821501381248, + "oil_price": 0.2955600657764731, + "bank_rate": 0.36261766908847626, + "eri": 0.11902426887495998, + "cpisa": 0.014076342222447637, + "cpi_energy": 0.7633597479985401, + "uk_gdp": 0.33490674258124664 + }, + "bvar_errors_by_origin": { + "world_gdp": [ + 0.8186197685180332, + 0.8189054595546281, + 0.7628504020331661, + -0.2824379756762596, + -0.6791372687712283, + -0.21302385892715847, + 0.01618022466197999, + -0.019519057097397763, + -0.3129740668089198, + -0.20728366746612892, + -0.3396757012977787, + -0.3800377003441895, + 0.2602134480607674, + 0.3511102537522106, + 0.14628912192506505, + 0.36336305676553593, + 0.36114993667024464, + -0.09177088242353193, + -0.5074544808348946, + -0.35002518880145317, + -0.3188792798283089, + -0.4799460685675285, + -0.010906267275004211, + 0.3613454914398062, + 0.15946745478322555, + 0.24954105955254136, + -0.3206603728251025, + -0.36368592240353337, + 0.08000421457347784, + 0.5427341273714887, + 3.3014142194100486, + 12.987748697103655, + 0.7801298734204352, + -11.802364003300283, + -1.4166894276116295, + -2.0896045444749234, + -2.345467025447931, + -1.719831267182201, + -0.6654449924712367, + -0.49001759382855425, + -0.6044495800861114, + -0.3951420588807082, + 0.018321500949809888, + -0.13433285535472805, + -0.23175488416796952, + -0.015145326524816483, + 0.06594603343575045, + -0.18728800456568706, + -0.5194176302046003 + ], + "world_cpi": [ + 0.1835223493564513, + 0.2838583793096632, + 0.1900030829125967, + 0.3683911328940326, + 0.43259790315607916, + 0.596046170328691, + 0.6438989541936735, + 0.29718717266018757, + 0.4264989092606015, + 1.0983069233266178, + 1.4865892943981862, + 0.2825730855502684, + -0.38755111825298627, + 0.9723238068041837, + 1.2840381288316394, + 0.1814795387612662, + -0.529686116709911, + 0.21257355953082424, + 0.11223781621430362, + -0.19249405422976906, + -0.0918582270933257, + 0.1416914358050576, + 0.05411524688247482, + -0.5240706087741387, + -0.7971064423553571, + 0.09367282227037776, + 0.8093909885424182, + -0.22516718356791898, + -0.5965113228920131, + 0.13460445629129936, + 0.4092139510494235, + 0.757392766934629, + 0.31187964454244366, + 0.060797303575384376, + -0.2217070398399983, + -1.4850002677948169, + -1.3355354746625494, + -1.6409076109445095, + -2.8427538632131473, + -3.7782627724387225, + -3.053093717944364, + -1.505617826847697, + -0.6974228834367864, + 0.026596274576604628, + -0.5218983533022765, + 0.4593058127886138, + 0.4665017495399866, + -0.48917274600677274, + -0.3586170896680301 + ], + "oil_price": [ + 16.981416065022245, + 9.829948460293906, + 6.380972138036043, + 8.15676082885983, + 8.718604752149929, + 8.27839519376272, + 17.360016582272124, + 10.495761855898934, + 12.372416511977633, + 38.03742054715525, + 59.75452551849003, + 22.601810633064986, + 14.384234743862294, + 41.800996751085336, + 32.02799281140699, + -7.775529924018372, + -32.767165238958796, + -13.940981026855525, + -12.847437912796295, + 11.275267090378918, + 15.80234045549031, + -10.766107239560029, + -13.861262304903391, + -13.000535932174216, + -16.297428277898234, + 7.959256728299863, + 19.57794359417005, + 0.846568440231465, + 0.6387875169410222, + 12.080453943581745, + 25.39881542019623, + 59.890944634026994, + 14.677632656959133, + -30.751991709291246, + -21.68045892710944, + -30.358497440588735, + -12.192632175895653, + -13.489623143350684, + -27.027006460267103, + -37.184691115250416, + -8.685636916186638, + 20.585507199658593, + 18.760168991182354, + 11.777767011782942, + -8.907828334089231, + -17.328188450987284, + -2.052831698591092, + -6.049215449260657, + 0.41602090500356326 + ], + "bank_rate": [ + -0.01843567328770901, + -0.05034979480907775, + -0.005264341433227293, + -0.16065920512773924, + -0.21897800489308195, + -0.00957494735413511, + 0.0567379176762256, + 0.08144508096300296, + 0.07945330626431879, + 0.14594927625330878, + 0.10026518575599752, + 0.012436845929698848, + 0.07234508622755986, + 0.23373221336364292, + 0.08018093688553862, + 0.0639277113630563, + 0.11235449043128459, + 0.4106539346755327, + -0.004389343990643668, + 0.011813156579609074, + 0.11309378256869768, + -0.015442908213927575, + -0.18371345611333784, + 0.08510810796320523, + -0.13656685773205446, + -0.20796931936686902, + -0.1591445641775363, + -0.09428393733897922, + -0.016110877743328755, + 0.03472486085084259, + 0.033147890750028774, + 0.6187638755757917, + -0.11021476539223721, + -0.8202800910674215, + 0.17874173978404442, + 0.14632683523500536, + 0.22448047823245806, + 0.16397915432934168, + -0.3252439892091633, + -0.8427250943757568, + -1.0899152341716123, + -1.766093631694173, + -2.2323015812748492, + -1.3685044995759674, + -1.1311410109800617, + -0.5609023088277372, + 0.08177467121202753, + -0.1107194085724128, + 0.08473853809601817 + ], + "eri": [ + -4.142811790710823, + -0.6864498823310896, + 4.872980601397558, + 3.297657582039392, + -2.218950803930852, + -3.845632362843446, + -5.244222466788756, + -3.5301628409236514, + -2.1253021382905217, + 0.5355806259384508, + -0.41942743837489616, + -3.039843441422306, + -1.3402761274747377, + 0.810794825696803, + 8.598789281918414, + 9.671095357336924, + 11.296271743840634, + 12.039905276010131, + 1.5418352001650533, + -2.436794819414672, + 0.5110456929634211, + 0.5390263767804981, + -3.340223542808019, + -1.8498584179132536, + 1.3212843152384721, + 1.182522424024512, + -2.1692786626753673, + -1.4334610646673696, + 4.087536078643154, + -1.9440105185971674, + -5.285485236123407, + 2.5268370385484786, + 0.8736385042880102, + -1.942681501853201, + -3.1691122954619004, + -4.354293071237237, + -1.3516601795614633, + 0.258388456508726, + -0.923493986416986, + 0.9071770659871845, + 4.30959401599921, + -0.14648448478709497, + -2.6755101977154254, + -5.628987185083417, + -6.908899582792458, + -1.9315202088511683, + -0.9931949160790623, + -3.2224017020728297, + -2.648751368511796 + ], + "cpisa": [ + 0.9315307738382899, + -0.3155675433291094, + -0.6377690052230491, + 0.6701614201731445, + 0.9229690993619215, + 0.23335837971148976, + 0.31994264435883224, + 0.8505086340630328, + 1.0257474599202965, + 0.948013537001259, + 1.4565019880164414, + 1.4942783158131192, + 0.595036836907127, + 0.5116774792704177, + 0.7763333355069335, + 0.9430960365129977, + 0.056617216256540814, + -0.44756191621354446, + -0.5437065166555612, + -0.3191095893794227, + -0.1911991459663227, + -0.6519650645104775, + -0.4527121992323373, + 0.30726307880729564, + 0.010722577105696018, + -0.30888422609388044, + 0.3932635642121909, + 0.5267609143193681, + -0.15327914955815913, + 0.2907440778126329, + 0.459181230181116, + 1.1088157397506393, + 0.8227914511837184, + -0.39066939774096454, + 0.1960434962888371, + -0.4876150323711954, + -1.0942306958426116, + -2.4263394509911222, + -2.7555321576443816, + -3.7218448170960983, + -3.916331953308031, + -2.3528201370116903, + -1.8655764739584697, + -0.6967601877383913, + -0.7249076624443092, + 0.8710846918893935, + 0.3730045941482558, + 0.08974020885312939, + 0.31886581517744617 + ], + "cpi_energy": [ + 5.744855061206067, + 3.2600233862972345, + -0.3508619210872439, + 1.6417921608372126, + 3.7580706409826234, + 3.74780389990849, + 3.2852315329108706, + 2.5181931673263307, + 3.8294012613881705, + 6.520573800670036, + 11.855529312117028, + 6.087967905494452, + 0.33684879501845444, + 6.946181821727805, + 7.2629128333969675, + 1.130799324088116, + -3.9716979719200936, + -1.6876166822642062, + -2.4966158297097536, + -0.026406811879496672, + 1.5448886234887595, + -1.3408423117085704, + -1.5977764500464673, + -1.295169954643825, + -4.209534687690052, + -2.4061358987894437, + 6.520524302984427, + 0.3179628467059956, + -5.932948929773374, + 5.325397506493232, + 5.595022408518616, + 9.776123099712436, + 5.222759941401364, + -2.3333574361665796, + 1.0965385040016145, + -9.444235768518183, + -7.7911397424940105, + -9.611536082028124, + -10.489914624975881, + -26.822014017152924, + -24.927586506548096, + -0.10081781133328604, + 2.3351989537136433, + 13.484371249353558, + 13.735888787131898, + 12.381071878423086, + 2.9985104067756083, + 4.616296202538592, + 10.921746130443012 + ], + "uk_gdp": [ + -0.4890147994719882, + -0.46365922465747644, + 0.5552215630373212, + -0.6052608336306093, + -1.1549463124392787, + -0.7770092563218896, + -0.7082106909624599, + -0.9140948327369642, + -0.8609230409149404, + -0.4386392171577427, + 0.11812245072178484, + 0.3917595024788625, + 0.5605071472766667, + 0.34372085456357127, + 0.1687183540479964, + 0.13393741080903965, + 0.19201332410580108, + 0.2767291107843448, + -0.5590719635549704, + -0.7472571645557764, + -0.3543395985675488, + -0.14964695769072023, + 0.3975781511860532, + 0.9369927813093, + 0.45447072473575645, + 0.46346463190616305, + 0.09773591749535626, + 0.03466537526924185, + 0.288821474210863, + 0.3019662356336994, + 3.597216675697382, + 25.86683910139368, + 6.476464039801613, + -22.042307890907296, + -0.9572799713098448, + -5.200288193253073, + -7.852088704168182, + -2.870589950631029, + -2.104726566753243, + -1.295858600371048, + -0.2204955921677083, + -0.3775327573823688, + -0.34257362229504906, + -0.16168668344721482, + 0.21222026846430708, + 0.63119193204966, + -0.3083504171088407, + -1.3994760839650553, + -0.837965911264746 + ] + }, + "random_walk_errors_by_origin": { + "world_gdp": [ + -0.15005000000002156, + -0.049474999999972624, + -0.17751099999998132, + -0.9385560000000055, + -1.2776320000000396, + -1.0948950000000082, + -0.9587939999999548, + -1.0198720000000208, + -1.3335440000000176, + -1.3036290000000008, + -1.4698119999999903, + -1.500620999999967, + -1.0974219999999946, + -1.0384779999999978, + -1.1562790000000405, + -0.9852940000000103, + -0.9822069999999599, + -1.450175999999999, + -1.6041770000000497, + -1.5311689999999771, + -1.5921409999999696, + -1.7984010000000126, + -1.3024010000000317, + -0.9935879999999884, + -0.9708289999999806, + -0.8534820000000423, + -1.2715559999999755, + -1.3168009999999981, + -1.067151000000024, + -0.5561979999999949, + 2.2840009999999893, + 11.955916000000002, + 0.6093089999999961, + -9.700417000000016, + -1.7631629999999632, + -3.06407999999999, + -3.466856000000007, + -2.438631999999984, + -1.4257620000000202, + -1.208769000000018, + -1.3387720000000058, + -0.8548789999999826, + -0.4857719999999972, + -0.6317230000000222, + -0.7495389999999702, + -0.5756690000000049, + -0.5184980000000223, + -0.6578669999999534, + -0.9562779999999975 + ], + "world_cpi": [ + -0.9088890000000447, + -0.7809159999999906, + -0.8940129999999726, + -0.6641610000000355, + -0.5965029999999842, + -0.45090899999996736, + -0.40381600000000617, + -0.6939480000000344, + -0.5113460000000032, + 0.11283500000001823, + 0.5619419999999877, + -0.5517929999999751, + -1.030807999999979, + 0.146191999999985, + 0.568367999999964, + -0.524468000000013, + -1.1507429999999772, + -0.5717720000000099, + -0.6956339999999841, + -0.9934449999999515, + -0.8650420000000167, + -0.5850800000000049, + -0.7030379999999923, + -1.3031950000000165, + -1.4926150000000007, + -0.650903000000028, + 0.026724999999999, + -0.9442159999999831, + -1.3258309999999938, + -0.5937589999999773, + -0.3680580000000191, + 0.08315599999997403, + -0.08372900000000527, + -0.17262699999997722, + -0.9957600000000184, + -2.1675820000000385, + -2.0459999999999923, + -2.4039109999999937, + -3.6657859999999687, + -4.710047999999972, + -4.193850999999995, + -3.2099440000000072, + -2.2250360000000455, + -1.640320000000031, + -1.7513779999999883, + -0.8698589999999626, + -0.7008149999999773, + -1.5218020000000365, + -1.398034999999993 + ], + "oil_price": [ + 8.471719000000007, + 1.9403059999999641, + -2.1714729999999918, + 3.2719210000000203, + 2.8764719999999784, + 0.322180000000003, + 9.533705999999995, + 4.087390999999968, + 6.572576000000026, + 30.51927900000004, + 53.06957999999997, + 16.645549999999957, + 9.700701000000038, + 34.17157100000003, + 28.826291999999967, + -11.948925000000031, + -36.918042999999955, + -21.535545999999954, + -19.59899200000001, + 4.722133999999983, + 11.516828999999973, + -13.547825999999986, + -17.527958000000012, + -16.45149600000002, + -17.984666000000004, + 5.069630000000018, + 18.381253000000015, + 0.38387599999998656, + -1.8488320000000158, + 9.85532999999998, + 23.653095000000008, + 59.07585900000004, + 17.37560400000001, + -23.755262000000016, + -26.976433999999983, + -35.16591699999998, + -16.081434, + -14.52120100000002, + -27.32149099999998, + -35.85238099999998, + -7.803020000000004, + 21.637348999999972, + 24.49144899999999, + 22.38617800000003, + 2.165590000000009, + -5.991422, + 6.023055999999997, + 0.34949799999998277, + 7.501820000000009 + ], + "bank_rate": [ + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.1577, + 0.25, + 0.0923, + 0.0, + 0.0, + -0.1587, + -0.25, + -0.09129999999999999, + -0.1602, + -0.25, + -0.08979999999999999, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.13829999999999998, + 0.65, + 0.5117, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + -0.02339999999999999, + -0.35629999999999995, + -0.8349000000000001, + -1.1609, + -1.8473000000000002, + -2.2383, + -1.6527000000000003, + -1.3046999999999995, + -0.7916999999999996, + -0.08980000000000032, + 0.0, + 0.1615000000000002 + ], + "eri": [ + -3.5196789999999964, + -0.5662510000000225, + 4.572347999999977, + 3.7882040000000075, + -1.126435000000015, + -3.696205999999961, + -5.192565999999999, + -3.9278300000000286, + -2.811931999999956, + -0.43989799999997103, + -1.5519429999999943, + -4.361991000000046, + -3.800590999999997, + -1.0503870000000006, + 6.552283999999986, + 7.47065200000003, + 9.837872000000004, + 11.057227000000012, + 2.266828999999973, + -1.7971689999999967, + 0.6337570000000028, + 0.31664200000000164, + -3.1631649999999922, + -1.7795880000000466, + 1.5431100000000129, + 1.6638149999999996, + -1.1970000000000027, + -0.7531009999999583, + 3.8527990000000045, + -1.3073290000000384, + -4.469258000000025, + 2.5531349999999975, + 2.263422999999989, + -0.6712459999999965, + -3.797905999999955, + -4.843779999999981, + -1.6285140000000524, + 0.20255300000002308, + -0.7030120000000011, + 1.7844169999999622, + 5.232671000000039, + 2.648742000000027, + -0.03198400000002266, + -2.9809379999999805, + -5.033456000000001, + -0.9352320000000418, + -0.44129399999997077, + -2.137250999999992, + -2.094154000000003 + ], + "cpisa": [ + -0.6713570000000004, + -1.7785460000000057, + -2.061904000000027, + -0.8653850000000034, + -0.6423509999999624, + -1.203536999999983, + -1.1168279999999982, + -0.5432320000000459, + -0.3249410000000239, + -0.35902999999996155, + 0.22438800000003312, + 0.39233500000000276, + -0.2576710000000162, + -0.4920860000000289, + -0.07677799999999024, + 0.15952800000002298, + -0.6196270000000368, + -1.3488380000000006, + -1.5274409999999534, + -1.3695210000000202, + -1.2428189999999972, + -1.6070819999999912, + -1.4334650000000124, + -0.7872859999999946, + -1.042852000000039, + -1.4507899999999836, + -0.7856989999999655, + -0.5480280000000448, + -1.0475040000000035, + -0.8449669999999969, + -0.5946710000000053, + 0.16699900000003254, + -0.019204999999999472, + -0.7493769999999813, + -0.6240809999999897, + -1.257380000000012, + -2.092657000000031, + -3.5167959999999994, + -3.9212969999999814, + -5.239514000000042, + -5.615135000000009, + -4.972586999999976, + -4.0778099999999995, + -3.12922199999997, + -2.4200230000000147, + -0.9435060000000135, + -1.0675099999999702, + -1.1454080000000317, + -0.9664589999999862 + ], + "cpi_energy": [ + 1.1097579999999425, + -0.7626710000000685, + -4.102800000000002, + -1.9480609999999388, + -0.03342299999997067, + 0.1173989999999776, + -0.4267340000000104, + -0.7377970000000005, + 0.6924199999999701, + 3.3250419999999394, + 9.032931000000076, + 4.166764000000057, + -0.2034280000000308, + 4.778854000000024, + 6.270427000000041, + 0.5567389999999932, + -3.8971290000000636, + -3.415727000000061, + -4.222433000000024, + -2.125462999999968, + -0.4625340000000051, + -2.7722029999999904, + -3.110435999999936, + -3.391527999999994, + -5.789758000000006, + -4.562898000000018, + 4.337087999999994, + -1.377187000000049, + -6.87596700000006, + 3.1341650000000527, + 3.881221000000096, + 8.618894999999952, + 5.596788999999944, + 0.9547380000000203, + -0.05580899999995381, + -10.127265999999963, + -9.448852999999986, + -11.612383000000023, + -12.541585000000055, + -30.118830000000003, + -28.653370999999993, + -9.53084100000001, + -3.775158000000033, + 7.088110000000029, + 10.839069999999992, + 10.154047999999989, + 2.5492940000000317, + 4.922463999999991, + 11.000481000000036 + ], + "uk_gdp": [ + -0.9779100000000653, + -0.8864610000000539, + -0.1204689999999573, + -0.9278609999998935, + -1.426093999999921, + -1.4204549999999472, + -1.455157999999983, + -1.734333000000106, + -1.747186000000056, + -1.4684700000000248, + -0.9609279999999671, + -0.7587060000000747, + -0.8425019999999677, + -0.984461999999894, + -1.0996110000000954, + -1.2350109999999859, + -1.1733819999999469, + -1.057596999999987, + -1.5665369999999257, + -1.798954999999978, + -1.523980000000165, + -1.422215000000051, + -0.8262209999998049, + -0.2958080000000791, + -0.5338890000000447, + -0.4462309999998979, + -0.6322390000000269, + -0.7155809999999292, + -0.7621280000000752, + -0.5550830000001952, + 2.7773200000001452, + 24.98041000000012, + 6.526946999999836, + -17.028890000000047, + -0.2767159999998512, + -5.667308999999932, + -8.421885000000202, + -3.0408250000000407, + -2.376494999999977, + -1.5646260000000893, + -0.6574409999998352, + -0.36097799999993185, + -0.3163710000001174, + -0.09780099999989034, + 0.19854099999997743, + 0.5618429999999535, + -0.40349399999990965, + -1.344712999999956, + -0.7981159999999363 + ] } }, { "horizon": 3, "variables_beating_random_walk": 4, + "n_origins": 49, "relative_rmse_by_variable": { "world_gdp": 0.9733527420706541, "world_cpi": 0.6912901531547437, @@ -105,11 +1839,852 @@ "cpisa": 2.8893101681713826, "cpi_energy": 11.328893147112822, "uk_gdp": 5.173587678973708 + }, + "dm_stat_by_variable": { + "world_gdp": -0.26621230885181385, + "world_cpi": -2.431337088630408, + "oil_price": 1.0930992272490674, + "bank_rate": -0.24185093940936733, + "eri": 1.6221845505237038, + "cpisa": -2.191975065612457, + "cpi_energy": 0.14687353468669598, + "uk_gdp": 0.8769108442698259 + }, + "dm_pvalue_by_variable": { + "world_gdp": 0.7912159328082999, + "world_cpi": 0.018826474855055432, + "oil_price": 0.279805974182469, + "bank_rate": 0.8099259628354544, + "eri": 0.1113147468970318, + "cpisa": 0.03326398048605383, + "cpi_energy": 0.8838470022923293, + "uk_gdp": 0.3849029180795347 + }, + "bvar_errors_by_origin": { + "world_gdp": [ + 1.3232871077734103, + 0.9936737060332916, + 0.5013124195013461, + -0.5214985343165495, + -0.8602542151115813, + -0.2446174001299255, + -0.1318638960779026, + -0.33853894319162237, + -0.3918110065606015, + -0.6616549991357488, + -0.3988941996431663, + -0.3349468192143945, + 0.4554665538661311, + 0.34136707637213703, + 0.49448122739016753, + 0.4430512871564929, + 0.30720656247149236, + -0.23532395041939935, + -0.6514537833023155, + -0.6191884887028323, + -0.6595316000401681, + -0.19951625661309436, + -0.0036677184599511747, + 0.636434355952872, + 0.210862005381955, + 0.02038053754597513, + -0.4012036415671787, + -0.35912621296358793, + 0.6170290323212839, + 3.396162069890522, + 13.458494797042931, + 4.525205128173695, + 0.5020647464957051, + -12.897707985587488, + -2.884326442635654, + -2.9769997643131205, + -2.795811890040113, + -1.7009633281574565, + -0.9182127891916707, + -0.6438149002008231, + -0.49642018932354404, + -0.40561792285825504, + -0.11274431585474076, + -0.2294061539307677, + -0.19940481741724625, + -0.0246102156426673, + -0.0708497769225005, + -0.5518833209287664, + -0.615303421540716 + ], + "world_cpi": [ + -0.027979916860999765, + 0.6929440223495931, + 0.20089950269363044, + 0.8172354946869405, + 0.5630230608591091, + 1.0902833806466106, + 0.4813434912347816, + 0.9483196343020381, + 0.8542231177161739, + 2.1910705750594275, + 0.7869004696209458, + 0.8395922603323243, + 0.011466871437903592, + 1.944081429756352, + 0.5963169518582276, + 0.47337330850893977, + -0.7069766387718346, + 0.3877904531686909, + -0.3195822691726562, + 0.10318918236475838, + -0.23865660682884027, + 0.3191481314050293, + -0.6961547178108844, + -0.5264469181378217, + -0.7062404013961441, + 0.7770329015093012, + -0.044239640765908916, + 0.06699543859758705, + -0.7331809984827373, + 0.658615457468045, + 0.7294015951781034, + 1.1034996326879423, + 0.46793280180082775, + -0.5417252037121898, + -1.2044263096930763, + -1.8925866363584305, + -2.665865211536868, + -3.262572847733111, + -5.187012295404884, + -4.840374994776539, + -4.317827306883601, + -1.3754011236685528, + -1.2583983551573397, + 0.09708600258215938, + -0.22772143866683336, + 0.6479197150359823, + -0.045790062711148494, + -0.25657030380438073, + -0.11125286812176682 + ], + "oil_price": [ + 23.62194455449537, + 8.765909679687638, + 18.013712626268727, + 6.012741795297927, + 17.315280246511406, + 15.393477734299097, + 20.190193927296264, + 19.688387016974616, + 38.86798119480221, + 69.61744067423149, + 49.790962724040696, + 47.40321245782394, + 29.177325448492752, + 60.80009522649772, + 5.511955432468312, + -13.719498409512255, + -44.095958127734434, + -18.211220005943517, + 0.30512973353654615, + 13.809126524039868, + 3.3402237284051353, + -12.533609438612416, + -25.15444249943306, + -16.66498015210084, + -5.025734731596742, + 17.270876502437716, + 12.351303711290768, + 7.917766880726958, + 5.6847369406628445, + 32.64122966358667, + 65.60124901457897, + 39.179333411689925, + 14.569610701828026, + -53.58935980524916, + -30.16075201491907, + -34.43486445129872, + -19.72624267013248, + -31.579793521664726, + -43.43898512921328, + -27.636730598749523, + 3.1623254783943935, + 31.434128529486884, + 27.165527978595605, + 0.38304670401743124, + -10.380813209111807, + -17.367934103182847, + -9.423103417121695, + 2.006582507293558, + 2.896807759231251 + ], + "bank_rate": [ + -0.05901948970833337, + -0.08727218935380449, + -0.02086537797388538, + -0.22335609548072055, + -0.2872961122115077, + -0.018197548197984692, + 0.05058683070184, + 0.08501952180434702, + 0.08863080337138785, + 0.1682179670651054, + 0.12736081772885743, + 0.05510100510443694, + 0.16915134661524367, + 0.3081083571459249, + 0.15860758535419062, + 0.314999543936428, + 0.2969979218215921, + 0.484145650306654, + 0.014289193624439367, + 0.037623455218809, + -0.007821936997533585, + -0.055331302679842376, + -0.14521911607307847, + -0.04002609227304099, + -0.223074663916766, + -0.21882801387227657, + -0.19875291922232874, + -0.12237089063931217, + 0.0015262856794504565, + 0.1543151365148855, + 0.523347545557626, + 0.6176828487818725, + -0.20727939183778446, + -0.8994472405925741, + 0.2403212444798075, + 0.19750974310792327, + 0.22775486516386462, + -0.16337263896278464, + -0.8435199161875603, + -1.5447500793404692, + -2.3288044844230282, + -2.9092619499029113, + -2.9196909029941285, + -2.1035111631925956, + -1.2712404040781156, + -0.5730756670984469, + 0.055595923324232466, + -0.019491643118453972, + 0.2679403691024831 + ], + "eri": [ + -4.095999833942415, + 3.129336655118834, + 4.526020541131004, + 2.2252319806922287, + -5.467833279137096, + -6.503557089780941, + -7.074819243107129, + -4.867995451687079, + -1.2229214941331747, + -1.7217253074502992, + -2.1442085008233107, + -4.3880034193028905, + 0.339380929793208, + 7.199974398395341, + 11.243806492531064, + 18.834496080450833, + 15.026438020112948, + 11.76485259824807, + 0.34836566355318155, + -0.8077510573065183, + -1.0737735998358175, + -1.1524417978931183, + -3.5244985400878477, + -0.34978065589524476, + 1.2363908079482826, + -0.2591206085456861, + -2.0110044194447028, + 1.7137641995842046, + -0.6629661960802764, + -1.9969505155941647, + -3.2290935768486975, + 2.3623902617327985, + 0.18681301363579905, + -5.004524518161475, + -4.7788901923867115, + -4.293217218392897, + -1.201142516180255, + -0.7099212481395512, + 1.650228420267922, + 3.2313134426518673, + 4.02214540910893, + -1.1814561206957137, + -6.416524105002452, + -8.813589343479691, + -6.512270458140904, + -4.2000177493496835, + -1.937952932944313, + -5.395244227737862, + -3.3352528424479146 + ], + "cpisa": [ + 0.5510316560881847, + -0.4188036323757842, + 0.10329634521457365, + 0.8048952198686266, + 1.1452282220994334, + 0.41957551497802115, + 1.0641293208120146, + 1.236232068269203, + 1.6999675167400028, + 1.87577967888285, + 2.2454672892940835, + 1.6868090834718146, + 1.0032261285091408, + 1.050205076836619, + 1.3842675137710785, + 0.6143291348623166, + -0.14281584877647902, + -0.9462444272099901, + -0.4998573853033008, + -0.6364445028687555, + -0.47442140884402306, + -0.8134176644892932, + -0.10408886494815306, + -0.05787297829817817, + -0.01587644146599132, + 0.008682582557867136, + 0.6406948945665931, + 0.33378501841997377, + 0.23837689654163796, + 0.35003533948344057, + 1.6336276214777854, + 0.9378685742758535, + 1.1967042636188125, + -0.6219407210891745, + -0.08703224483843996, + -1.4445861598924807, + -2.760664187394127, + -3.712592623517139, + -5.691984765286293, + -5.276167253869119, + -6.066474582720616, + -2.705128165440385, + -2.907002471898977, + -0.32867290884490785, + -0.37463120291425867, + 1.005320929572406, + 0.6225564489756152, + 0.25755347573345944, + 0.19201540198963585 + ], + "cpi_energy": [ + 6.568216440616652, + 2.838173500643279, + 2.2631986930559833, + 2.8832718223646907, + 6.477608553317054, + 4.447485260310032, + 5.582790638416782, + 4.463293894004778, + 8.568762569878913, + 14.099771158477097, + 11.582741387321448, + 8.921463565014164, + 4.383865006637052, + 11.084220530020502, + 5.527258470914262, + 0.3478511182137254, + -5.674480355561059, + -3.1575051659981455, + -1.7130148459822294, + 0.27942290151895577, + 0.15331423833902136, + -1.4576139587809394, + -3.372309134147258, + -3.6616717116858126, + -4.70002263062247, + 4.176501447713804, + 0.48550323529195794, + 1.3786696460297208, + -2.1750653388335195, + 7.1788028590773365, + 14.221294981408732, + 8.389718683436286, + 8.732134948579528, + -5.798759774805944, + -5.383568915508931, + -11.550219254459762, + -16.36131785821169, + -12.25950102101092, + -36.44269835622299, + -27.689839349466524, + -31.348250666723743, + 6.408295946577027, + 7.5457242315568465, + 23.262257715146802, + 17.551637541780906, + 13.325977288791705, + 8.198641178014327, + 10.728340494001259, + 8.934266931171464 + ], + "uk_gdp": [ + -0.172760995415274, + -0.546176655466752, + 0.15188116900208115, + -1.1884231158778675, + -1.652795930164075, + -1.3033281728526163, + -1.3617159143270783, + -1.3961779001635932, + -1.1509727133843626, + -0.3397122487538127, + 0.1109863131352995, + 0.548162144950993, + 0.652884873006542, + 0.43009560522341417, + 0.09776896191192463, + 0.4056238861908241, + 0.32653994375846196, + -0.03918464013236189, + -0.8563650441849404, + -0.8896981266968851, + -0.5497206233258112, + 0.3839935892806352, + 0.7829321464907935, + 1.1755736577511016, + 0.8266272231865059, + 0.3966235568659613, + 0.26882718710544395, + -0.09513428588115858, + 0.7917116220573917, + 3.4970814496234652, + 26.233197404648763, + 10.665900371091993, + 5.452526138142957, + -21.67389001916672, + -7.4332865430703805, + -6.4465015785899595, + -8.95983511625036, + -3.532489846244971, + -2.3152306833408147, + -1.1066740204082635, + -0.2743151403706179, + -0.44047098551368435, + -0.3437130910213, + 0.09761591540836889, + 0.5830292879147692, + -0.02760188282513809, + -0.9414878813465748, + -1.6200877090234371, + -1.237839495561957 + ] + }, + "random_walk_errors_by_origin": { + "world_gdp": [ + -0.08019100000001345, + -0.29684499999996206, + -0.8686969999999974, + -1.525002000000029, + -1.7860810000000242, + -1.5452399999999784, + -1.5283210000000054, + -1.7838889999999878, + -1.8731560000000513, + -2.2338289999999574, + -2.0402330000000006, + -2.027621999999951, + -1.608899000000008, + -1.6832800000000248, + -1.4967710000000238, + -1.6270089999999868, + -1.7906679999999824, + -2.245892000000026, + -2.3396299999999997, + -2.387856999999997, + -2.5338539999999625, + -2.1590890000000513, + -1.9353009999999813, + -1.3315170000000194, + -1.4863819999999919, + -1.6094850000000065, + -1.8323540000000094, + -1.8231539999999882, + -1.1169960000000287, + 1.7776479999999992, + 11.906070999999997, + 2.94315499999999, + -0.07834700000000794, + -10.775923999999975, + -3.751735999999994, + -4.542362999999966, + -4.427205000000015, + -2.9040449999999964, + -2.169118000000026, + -1.8041850000000181, + -1.5982349999999883, + -1.0811879999999974, + -0.8911860000000047, + -0.975847999999985, + -0.9810830000000124, + -0.862622999999985, + -0.8894109999999955, + -1.2432319999999777, + -1.293450000000007 + ], + "world_cpi": [ + -1.6621220000000108, + -0.9216959999999972, + -1.4173940000000016, + -0.7372829999999908, + -0.9742899999999963, + -0.47693799999996145, + -1.0717350000000465, + -0.5373749999999973, + -0.5550840000000221, + 0.7185150000000249, + -0.595530999999994, + -0.4251279999999724, + -1.0112809999999968, + 0.6950329999999667, + -0.5049410000000307, + -0.6019019999999955, + -1.6450810000000047, + -0.7730679999999666, + -1.487782999999979, + -1.0663379999999734, + -1.3772289999999998, + -0.7759310000000141, + -1.8153819999999996, + -1.68346600000001, + -1.7632470000000353, + -0.35354599999999436, + -1.2148480000000177, + -1.0284739999999601, + -1.835331999999994, + -0.45231599999999617, + -0.4263450000000262, + 0.05771399999997584, + -0.2309139999999843, + -1.0212020000000166, + -2.3147670000000176, + -2.8945750000000317, + -3.722917999999993, + -4.392778999999962, + -6.386965999999973, + -6.182718999999963, + -5.931124000000011, + -3.6977070000000367, + -3.377593000000047, + -2.239141000000018, + -2.0224159999999642, + -1.299635999999964, + -1.7928400000000124, + -1.8278119999999944, + -1.690953000000036 + ], + "oil_price": [ + 11.042552, + -2.802000000000021, + 5.8427540000000135, + -1.8658340000000067, + 8.336407000000008, + 4.395950999999968, + 9.547325999999998, + 10.646346999999992, + 30.532899000000043, + 59.628536, + 40.605872999999974, + 38.809957999999995, + 21.70786400000003, + 50.990700000000004, + 0.058237999999960266, + -20.09891399999998, + -50.30359999999996, + -27.748980999999958, + -8.663423000000023, + 5.303393999999969, + -2.6122569999999996, + -16.946698000000026, + -30.580581999999993, + -21.383538000000044, + -7.982993999999962, + 13.449210999999991, + 10.385548000000028, + 6.5307489999999575, + 1.859624999999994, + 29.79996799999998, + 62.78431600000005, + 37.32024200000001, + 15.375959000000023, + -48.73205100000001, + -37.165561999999966, + -41.058223, + -24.710329, + -33.213797, + -44.48127599999998, + -26.495615999999984, + 4.477563999999973, + 33.848213999999984, + 34.666762000000006, + 14.376455000000021, + 4.183891000000017, + -1.9866670000000113, + 2.367798999999991, + 11.506574999999998, + 13.108047 + ], + "bank_rate": [ + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.1577, + 0.25, + 0.25, + 0.0923, + 0.0, + -0.1587, + -0.25, + -0.25, + -0.2515, + -0.25, + -0.25, + -0.08979999999999999, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.13829999999999998, + 0.65, + 0.65, + 0.5117, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + -0.02339999999999999, + -0.35629999999999995, + -0.8583000000000001, + -1.4938, + -2.3493, + -2.8972, + -2.8411000000000004, + -2.3545999999999996, + -1.3944999999999999, + -0.7916999999999996, + -0.08980000000000032, + 0.1615000000000002, + 0.39449999999999985 + ], + "eri": [ + -2.978259000000037, + 3.4646769999999947, + 4.329623999999967, + 2.904493000000002, + -3.9389299999999707, + -6.076277000000005, + -6.740324999999984, + -5.192003, + -1.987656999999956, + -2.8161159999999654, + -3.537716000000046, + -6.176808999999992, + -3.036160000000052, + 4.73746600000004, + 8.235082999999975, + 15.625725000000045, + 12.740026, + 10.421901999999989, + 1.1049849999999992, + -0.0015680000000202199, + -0.845201999999972, + -1.3675640000000158, + -3.2585470000000214, + -0.14109600000000455, + 1.5684329999999704, + 0.4414920000000393, + -0.7277780000000007, + 2.6304760000000442, + -0.8381070000000364, + -1.0856810000000223, + -2.1377710000000434, + 2.485071000000005, + 1.660240999999985, + -3.8659699999999475, + -5.446961999999985, + -4.8232380000000035, + -1.446503000000007, + -0.6824700000000234, + 1.9664280000000076, + 4.347647999999992, + 5.318182000000036, + 2.5312470000000076, + -2.8954269999999838, + -5.1509510000000205, + -3.798675000000003, + -2.6113070000000107, + -0.9024699999999939, + -3.770228999999972, + -2.425422000000026 + ], + "cpisa": [ + -1.8733809999999949, + -2.638426000000038, + -2.067408999999998, + -1.5022309999999948, + -1.209041999999954, + -1.7536739999999895, + -1.1099230000000375, + -0.8750780000000304, + -0.3521250000000009, + -0.10745799999995143, + 0.36515100000002576, + -0.006099000000006072, + -0.35132300000003625, + -0.4752119999999991, + 0.06587600000000293, + -0.602753000000007, + -1.2061840000000075, + -2.2897219999999834, + -1.9560779999999909, + -2.18370299999998, + -2.0357190000000287, + -2.247646999999972, + -1.580186000000026, + -1.68341700000002, + -1.5975109999999972, + -1.6818299999999908, + -1.102687000000003, + -1.2785440000000108, + -1.1619550000000345, + -1.3251869999999712, + 0.05254800000000159, + -0.4994249999999738, + -0.10215799999997444, + -1.290504999999996, + -1.340332999999987, + -2.633785000000046, + -4.233047999999997, + -5.297702000000015, + -7.379905000000008, + -7.396041000000025, + -8.431195000000002, + -6.234336999999982, + -5.945281999999963, + -3.681773000000021, + -2.8109779999999773, + -1.620061000000021, + -1.5363629999999944, + -1.6430139999999938, + -1.7686760000000277 + ], + "cpi_energy": [ + -0.44054400000004534, + -3.3151690000000826, + -3.4983629999999266, + -2.585920999999985, + 0.721836000000053, + -1.0645940000000564, + 0.01746200000002318, + -0.489573000000064, + 3.769237999999973, + 9.281155000000012, + 7.24358200000006, + 5.752685000000042, + 2.9895050000000083, + 7.856348000000025, + 3.7496720000000323, + -0.8196350000000621, + -5.936482000000069, + -5.598807000000079, + -4.164815999999973, + -2.6456140000000232, + -2.71458599999994, + -3.6305869999999913, + -5.643579999999929, + -6.648142000000007, + -7.096042000000011, + 1.080473999999981, + -2.683471000000054, + -1.2325950000000603, + -3.8863939999999957, + 4.025813000000085, + 11.608468000000016, + 6.488436999999976, + 8.68198499999994, + -2.18626699999993, + -7.042069999999967, + -12.589857999999936, + -18.598644000000036, + -15.004177000000027, + -39.26862100000005, + -32.045165, + -36.25787700000001, + -5.701493000000028, + -0.5163959999999861, + 14.668417999999974, + 13.412810000000036, + 10.129601999999977, + 7.496204000000034, + 10.976035000000024, + 8.924617000000012 + ], + "uk_gdp": [ + -0.8334310000000187, + -1.1514090000000579, + -0.7833819999998468, + -1.6910419999999249, + -2.0833679999998367, + -2.2183390000000145, + -2.391607000000022, + -2.5450700000001234, + -2.4049190000000635, + -1.7716649999999845, + -1.4164390000000822, + -1.1456969999999274, + -1.439973000000009, + -1.486601999999948, + -1.8324820000000273, + -1.6755220000000008, + -1.790467999999919, + -2.0070479999999407, + -2.41604099999995, + -2.4734310000001187, + -2.2717190000000755, + -1.5006969999999455, + -1.0435469999999896, + -0.6123709999999392, + -0.6635570000000826, + -0.9488019999998869, + -0.845248999999967, + -1.2646990000000642, + -0.7680930000001354, + 2.2282020000000102, + 24.97444500000006, + 9.310232000000042, + 5.168234999999868, + -15.94689399999993, + -7.026020999999901, + -7.339889000000085, + -9.79013000000009, + -4.04907500000013, + -2.9328709999999774, + -1.6656909999999243, + -0.9173539999999321, + -0.4174359999999524, + -0.3577139999999872, + 0.14208299999995688, + 0.5205000000000837, + -0.16361000000006243, + -1.0227539999998498, + -1.5235689999999522, + -1.2302750000001197 + ] } }, { "horizon": 4, "variables_beating_random_walk": 3, + "n_origins": 49, "relative_rmse_by_variable": { "world_gdp": 0.9252177990458005, "world_cpi": 0.6883541904477545, @@ -139,11 +2714,852 @@ "cpisa": 3.7841280819677814, "cpi_energy": 13.878861845090672, "uk_gdp": 5.991552667813123 + }, + "dm_stat_by_variable": { + "world_gdp": -0.6704479501096022, + "world_cpi": -2.184489066620781, + "oil_price": 0.9020186989990556, + "bank_rate": 0.9217335404482448, + "eri": 1.7262478117653972, + "cpisa": -1.9687523961674398, + "cpi_energy": 0.45228012625224845, + "uk_gdp": 0.8294857279104415 + }, + "dm_pvalue_by_variable": { + "world_gdp": 0.5057854205975694, + "world_cpi": 0.03384228514852752, + "oil_price": 0.3715510845843478, + "bank_rate": 0.36127741909445765, + "eri": 0.09073503365682105, + "cpisa": 0.05477025263873361, + "cpi_energy": 0.6531046331073073, + "uk_gdp": 0.4109358680635671 + }, + "bvar_errors_by_origin": { + "world_gdp": [ + 1.4841865400607048, + 0.7080801948036992, + 0.31386856222377446, + -0.6740947277588134, + -0.9812094249616052, + -0.42258748456305284, + -0.505928587657877, + -0.46154257595941317, + -0.888830019550312, + -0.7923959472179831, + -0.4484933332043397, + -0.2937772100677307, + 0.4897906724360723, + 0.6126329483350332, + 0.5365155646825315, + 0.35016453296026384, + 0.27071071194563956, + -0.3291671830344285, + -0.9035810357087257, + -0.9759208203787466, + -0.43242524549788186, + -0.2021783721503425, + 0.29200301479238533, + 0.7153752047601074, + 0.02234586699501051, + -0.01740009548962007, + -0.41865036547130785, + 0.1104271708259148, + 3.5213736513029517, + 13.539487712365656, + 4.986870346567912, + 4.389230982834533, + -0.06911166689286574, + -14.678250847693448, + -3.8134532443500007, + -3.3753791400832256, + -2.764361737541549, + -1.9498845364066142, + -1.011156445856841, + -0.43090894360830134, + -0.34156521126521966, + -0.5538596902123345, + -0.1631834625893589, + -0.19582653542033768, + -0.2168451226967818, + -0.11237554991652132, + -0.4284181048075766, + -0.6561398891204249, + -0.7434051876330159 + ], + "world_cpi": [ + 0.3685781385390783, + 0.7209152373579855, + 0.65648071102828, + 0.9660845708548891, + 1.0457794104993923, + 0.9384803506072217, + 1.13744238461112, + 1.3953716271390704, + 1.928681797843467, + 1.5150909285845842, + 1.367487416537017, + 1.2896914945962408, + 0.9472997050833669, + 1.2949587796417177, + 0.9102081836298908, + 0.3528073726051275, + -0.5867172683277317, + -0.026939885103558936, + -0.03626009855150869, + -0.04318028334131441, + -0.06661098202198446, + -0.4219261717653353, + -0.7160014333874756, + -0.42135658206740345, + -0.044949824003651884, + -0.07670941599400294, + 0.25768824283022695, + -0.06341805607377182, + -0.22066326620830523, + 0.9871497338957624, + 1.0791987532787175, + 1.3346758290738308, + -0.056127346267089706, + -1.5873882409924818, + -1.6037082353479946, + -3.24659540973164, + -4.306222457896695, + -5.6161510211299515, + -6.285492710861718, + -6.174563985544637, + -4.353174808965036, + -1.9795317913743133, + -1.3021220246303642, + 0.445757601973753, + -0.09727776452376702, + 0.1598766934459377, + 0.23034813212882455, + -0.0015699587721655917, + -0.03559800062760132 + ], + "oil_price": [ + 22.745249487537478, + 20.25156820760293, + 16.139459624461324, + 14.602392072732243, + 24.5007082830773, + 18.092775956759965, + 29.272736241395194, + 46.020710782073195, + 70.26469074617137, + 59.270292098918446, + 74.08741130360977, + 61.676083345309735, + 48.35861191080005, + 34.00478656395234, + -0.5216450973763358, + -25.106791811300354, + -48.52416911418652, + -5.4977942913614015, + 2.8368989073642865, + 1.4521313894402397, + 1.518404958311237, + -23.962917902655477, + -28.465404706414972, + -5.449156465395049, + 4.599595515002477, + 10.224474687056102, + 19.31570829249472, + 12.587889875099734, + 26.704159041829428, + 72.52861828004939, + 44.83063003616866, + 38.233095718166, + -8.336691096135326, + -61.08609713698411, + -34.444705331002694, + -41.434901870966485, + -37.279075857688724, + -47.81793226676416, + -33.14637432233707, + -14.709351516916342, + 15.20031891678991, + 40.46967383509764, + 17.741477924037213, + -0.31458473113201535, + -9.411123037980076, + -24.568697709283754, + -1.7832408253268, + 4.6527356930724295, + -2.195894137833477 + ], + "bank_rate": [ + -0.11672137685065614, + -0.13281496195246045, + -0.054903874824319965, + -0.27529033402818676, + -0.3461946414613246, + -0.044285137640377836, + 0.02249244069874623, + 0.06790396308270785, + 0.07864852188592586, + 0.16238690612076445, + 0.13201734697300604, + 0.08962983529568502, + 0.2558021016247116, + 0.36223544398381624, + 0.39677500552510986, + 0.5027886567648394, + 0.40408387246616684, + 0.5483470197554317, + 0.049761890068743875, + -0.09482987338569171, + -0.0718056296162985, + -0.013330761573059069, + -0.2691316337501109, + -0.11139225013633991, + -0.21868510095983762, + -0.23419761229845892, + -0.23122336794133835, + -0.14201918240881573, + 0.14973072347532634, + 0.6455135827274883, + 0.5109524826568984, + 0.6182518636856827, + -0.21969290233325206, + -0.8746551132079156, + 0.28060258198011223, + 0.21326895278931557, + -0.09501351716211681, + -0.6711728999231719, + -1.5168084005662579, + -2.7672332875329757, + -3.435673630056077, + -3.6137311967904915, + -3.713212964382023, + -2.2614552479132275, + -1.338666492812091, + -0.6096905157383974, + 0.17570822632245253, + 0.15172323617370687, + 0.476106352524547 + ], + "eri": [ + -0.626471788950596, + 2.616947481715158, + 3.450424453247706, + -0.7704413818585749, + -8.292104533302904, + -8.401543769789669, + -8.695244110894123, + -4.193160539703399, + -3.6001647981229894, + -3.6765893056409595, + -3.8005591662861775, + -3.2566753829912614, + 6.883085580392958, + 9.428414862514046, + 20.281678294018093, + 22.66261211659497, + 15.153974866054057, + 10.955375689211053, + 2.142329422137948, + -2.4391417552528765, + -2.8909220576236976, + -1.2858729205426016, + -1.9957962022093625, + -0.4832528288338267, + -0.10324843079257562, + 0.010664773791859261, + 1.0899889855202787, + -3.207500467601278, + -0.5626917340843534, + 0.08851343733789463, + -3.5684512323597346, + 1.6455045020076682, + -2.9849022123111695, + -6.405529780282961, + -4.77168888892129, + -4.098633352518448, + -2.1218969957680542, + 1.8964003106383984, + 4.137863921198914, + 3.1479993093146845, + 3.59523966871285, + -4.778487112161372, + -9.335863127414996, + -8.47342715640201, + -8.97368727516789, + -5.24334731378184, + -4.049724749720383, + -6.249369629431612, + -3.050397299513918 + ], + "cpisa": [ + 0.5206312044101651, + 0.34037485106227905, + 0.2205599378826264, + 1.0153411793875193, + 1.3899710226164643, + 1.1675690516024133, + 1.4746362232168053, + 1.9316711856464508, + 2.6589090817248007, + 2.6966129734078095, + 2.502008479323081, + 2.191322306101256, + 1.5380316149378928, + 1.716764402311071, + 1.0971398875657883, + 0.47020567195221474, + -0.6886023711246025, + -0.9357341139007076, + -0.8475515242010943, + -0.9368979534547748, + -0.6050323515167406, + -0.4767944082079225, + -0.5029412599266152, + -0.08285538278835247, + 0.2843330559409196, + 0.23669284463647955, + 0.47051097998144087, + 0.7598536709022596, + 0.27733669378636705, + 1.5301743520960827, + 1.4948684898841407, + 1.3587634711402075, + 1.1198583026549045, + -0.997069144871034, + -1.0261274812363013, + -3.1594418998212177, + -4.071433513852696, + -6.68593240316153, + -7.334642132806891, + -7.520780932413061, + -6.700037862986051, + -3.778954935931779, + -2.6914652291752077, + 0.11629802960106872, + -0.3213175928281089, + 1.3189073115730139, + 0.8484641289340402, + 0.13529920094902081, + -0.11731240738373572 + ], + "cpi_energy": [ + 6.390036831522707, + 5.594002845596492, + 3.6268207474448673, + 5.561206934672782, + 7.283782161839781, + 6.757803849910147, + 7.66154005097053, + 9.227540320984986, + 16.181720793612158, + 13.904574844824538, + 14.672629089504767, + 13.380752221184025, + 8.384764205695205, + 9.611260742841978, + 4.989400201464036, + -1.050106403324662, + -7.470875378379901, + -2.4106043868338247, + -1.5375465080222739, + -1.1798244738581616, + 0.13795081122816555, + -3.230224331614977, + -5.87210566052147, + -4.101706614741829, + 1.7754392233440512, + -1.9190086149216086, + 1.604112422371145, + 5.308552499224788, + -0.4884151202261364, + 15.859867394892149, + 12.989872092613382, + 12.2661703942332, + 6.1529155350986, + -12.813798628683344, + -7.364264024923614, + -20.328845621654978, + -19.196481772056472, + -38.284286255780444, + -37.62134369297257, + -34.328077366335265, + -26.450682388249902, + 11.755324543768324, + 16.87011854038144, + 27.752589230672015, + 18.76727810833711, + 19.208911794808955, + 14.526980238914234, + 8.765590154780853, + 7.13887755206224 + ], + "uk_gdp": [ + -0.3012433429514658, + -1.0515314108297389, + -0.39037304465728084, + -1.6619610929244573, + -2.291292727149994, + -2.00106349769203, + -1.9263595877905573, + -1.7604779767596028, + -1.1200903010976617, + -0.43705138321729464, + 0.13188507828704132, + 0.46705951030958204, + 0.8034843672526222, + 0.25662575513615593, + 0.31016114853628096, + 0.49055192718765284, + 0.1330749426233524, + -0.26795992391157597, + -0.9620981721789121, + -1.1066308838612713, + -0.09066778131091269, + 0.7647991199266926, + 1.061279415766876, + 1.5806465463113, + 0.8239038060094117, + 0.6148354159633982, + 0.11381097513708482, + 0.326379761013186, + 4.060757845960779, + 26.1090997481283, + 11.00820104318882, + 9.771298075242385, + 6.960918363291057, + -28.76339575752104, + -8.765807525587661, + -7.427334514043423, + -9.724917687389961, + -3.743861725421084, + -2.0623127845822182, + -1.0480734576797204, + -0.11868660689378885, + -0.44988911001200904, + -0.03399739790802414, + 0.46333211183423373, + -0.07718401681950127, + -0.5688994654963153, + -1.1357993515189264, + -2.0733331609485504, + -1.7664305540872647 + ] + }, + "random_walk_errors_by_origin": { + "world_gdp": [ + -0.3275610000000029, + -0.9880309999999781, + -1.455143000000021, + -2.0334510000000137, + -2.2364259999999945, + -2.114767000000029, + -2.2923379999999725, + -2.3235010000000216, + -2.803356000000008, + -2.8042499999999677, + -2.567233999999985, + -2.5390989999999647, + -2.253701000000035, + -2.023772000000008, + -2.1384860000000003, + -2.4354700000000093, + -2.5863840000000096, + -2.981344999999976, + -3.1963180000000193, + -3.3295699999999897, + -2.8945420000000013, + -2.791989000000001, + -2.2732300000000123, + -1.8470700000000306, + -2.242384999999956, + -2.1702830000000404, + -2.3387069999999994, + -1.872998999999993, + 1.2168499999999653, + 11.399718000000007, + 2.8933099999999854, + 2.255498999999986, + -1.153853999999967, + -12.764497000000006, + -5.23001899999997, + -5.502711999999974, + -4.892618000000027, + -3.647401000000002, + -2.764534000000026, + -2.0636480000000006, + -1.824544000000003, + -1.4866020000000049, + -1.2353109999999674, + -1.207392000000027, + -1.2680369999999925, + -1.2335359999999582, + -1.4747760000000198, + -1.5804039999999873, + -1.6716069999999945 + ], + "world_cpi": [ + -1.8029020000000173, + -1.4450770000000261, + -1.4905159999999569, + -1.115070000000003, + -1.0003189999999904, + -1.1448570000000018, + -0.9151620000000094, + -0.5811130000000162, + 0.05059599999998454, + -0.4389579999999569, + -0.46886599999999135, + -0.4056009999999901, + -0.46244000000001506, + -0.37827600000002803, + -0.5823750000000132, + -1.096240000000023, + -1.8463769999999613, + -1.5652169999999614, + -1.5606760000000008, + -1.5785249999999564, + -1.568080000000009, + -1.8882750000000215, + -2.195652999999993, + -1.9540980000000445, + -1.4658900000000017, + -1.595119000000011, + -1.2991059999999948, + -1.5379749999999603, + -1.6938890000000129, + -0.5106030000000032, + -0.45178700000002436, + -0.08947100000000319, + -1.0794890000000237, + -2.3402090000000157, + -3.0417600000000107, + -4.571493000000032, + -5.711785999999961, + -7.113958999999966, + -7.859636999999964, + -7.919991999999979, + -6.418887000000041, + -4.850264000000038, + -3.976414000000034, + -2.5101789999999937, + -2.4521929999999657, + -2.391660999999999, + -2.0988499999999704, + -2.1207300000000373, + -2.1597360000000094 + ], + "oil_price": [ + 6.300246000000016, + 5.212226999999984, + 0.7049989999999866, + 3.5941010000000233, + 12.410177999999974, + 4.409570999999971, + 16.10628200000002, + 34.60667000000001, + 59.642156, + 47.164829, + 62.77028100000001, + 50.817120999999986, + 38.526993000000004, + 22.222645999999997, + -8.091750999999988, + -33.484470999999985, + -56.517034999999964, + -16.81341199999997, + -8.082163000000037, + -8.825692000000004, + -6.0111290000000395, + -29.999322000000006, + -35.51262400000002, + -11.381866000000002, + 0.3965870000000109, + 5.453506000000004, + 16.532421, + 10.239205999999967, + 21.80426299999999, + 68.93118900000002, + 41.02869900000002, + 35.32059700000002, + -9.600829999999974, + -58.921178999999995, + -43.057867999999985, + -49.687118, + -43.40292499999998, + -50.373582, + -35.124510999999984, + -14.215032000000008, + 16.688428999999985, + 44.023527, + 26.657038999999997, + 16.39475600000003, + 8.188646000000006, + -5.641924000000017, + 13.524876000000006, + 17.112801999999988, + 10.92224699999997 + ], + "bank_rate": [ + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.1577, + 0.25, + 0.25, + 0.25, + 0.0923, + -0.1587, + -0.25, + -0.25, + -0.4102, + -0.3413, + -0.25, + -0.25, + -0.08979999999999999, + 0.0, + 0.13829999999999998, + 0.65, + 0.65, + 0.65, + 0.5117, + 0.0, + 0.0, + -0.02339999999999999, + -0.35629999999999995, + -0.8583000000000001, + -1.5171999999999999, + -2.6822, + -3.3992, + -3.5000000000000004, + -3.5429999999999997, + -2.4444, + -1.3944999999999999, + -0.7916999999999996, + 0.07169999999999987, + 0.39449999999999985, + 0.6508000000000003 + ], + "eri": [ + 1.0526689999999803, + 3.221952999999985, + 3.445912999999962, + 0.09199800000004643, + -6.319001000000014, + -7.62403599999999, + -8.004497999999955, + -4.367728, + -4.36387499999995, + -4.801889000000017, + -5.3525339999999915, + -5.4123780000000465, + 2.751692999999989, + 6.420265000000029, + 16.39015599999999, + 18.52787900000004, + 12.104700999999977, + 9.260058000000015, + 2.9005859999999757, + -1.480526999999995, + -2.5294079999999894, + -1.462946000000045, + -1.6200549999999794, + -0.11577300000004698, + 0.34611000000001013, + 0.9107140000000413, + 2.655799000000002, + -2.0604299999999967, + -0.6164590000000203, + 1.2458059999999591, + -2.205835000000036, + 1.881889000000001, + -1.534482999999966, + -5.515025999999978, + -5.426420000000007, + -4.641226999999958, + -2.3315260000000535, + 1.9869699999999852, + 4.529659000000038, + 4.433158999999989, + 5.200687000000016, + -0.33219599999995353, + -5.065440000000024, + -3.9161700000000224, + -5.474749999999972, + -3.072483000000034, + -2.535447999999974, + -4.101496999999995, + -1.7851029999999923 + ], + "cpisa": [ + -2.7332610000000273, + -2.643931000000009, + -2.704254999999989, + -2.0689219999999864, + -1.7591789999999605, + -1.7467690000000289, + -1.441769000000022, + -0.9022620000000074, + -0.10055299999999079, + 0.03330500000004122, + -0.033282999999983076, + -0.09975100000002612, + -0.33444900000000644, + -0.3325580000000059, + -0.696405000000027, + -1.1893099999999777, + -2.14706799999999, + -2.718359000000021, + -2.7702599999999507, + -2.9766030000000114, + -2.6762840000000097, + -2.394367999999986, + -2.4763170000000514, + -2.238075999999978, + -1.8285510000000045, + -1.9988180000000284, + -1.833202999999969, + -1.3929950000000417, + -1.6421750000000088, + -0.6779679999999644, + -0.6138760000000048, + -0.5823779999999488, + -0.6432859999999891, + -2.0067569999999932, + -2.7167380000000207, + -4.774176000000011, + -6.0139540000000125, + -8.756310000000042, + -9.53643199999999, + -10.212101000000018, + -9.692945000000009, + -8.101808999999946, + -6.497833000000014, + -4.072727999999984, + -3.487532999999985, + -2.0889140000000452, + -2.0339689999999564, + -2.4452310000000352, + -2.758966999999984 + ], + "cpi_energy": [ + -2.9930420000000595, + -2.7107320000000072, + -4.136222999999973, + -1.8306619999999612, + -0.46015699999998105, + -0.6203980000000229, + 0.2656859999999597, + 2.587244999999939, + 9.725351000000046, + 7.491805999999997, + 8.829503000000045, + 8.945618000000081, + 6.06699900000001, + 5.335593000000017, + 2.373297999999977, + -2.8589880000000676, + -8.119562000000087, + -5.541190000000029, + -4.684967000000029, + -4.897665999999958, + -3.572969999999941, + -6.163730999999984, + -8.900193999999942, + -7.954426000000012, + -1.452670000000012, + -5.940085000000067, + -2.5388790000000654, + 1.7569780000000037, + -2.9947459999999637, + 11.753060000000005, + 9.47801000000004, + 9.573632999999973, + 5.5409799999999905, + -9.172527999999943, + -9.50466199999994, + -21.739648999999986, + -21.99043800000004, + -41.731213000000025, + -41.19495600000005, + -39.64967100000001, + -32.428529000000026, + -2.4427309999999807, + 7.063911999999959, + 17.242158000000018, + 13.388364000000024, + 15.07651199999998, + 13.549775000000068, + 8.900171, + 7.01242000000002 + ], + "uk_gdp": [ + -1.0983790000000226, + -1.8143219999999474, + -1.5465629999998782, + -2.3483159999998406, + -2.881251999999904, + -3.154788000000053, + -3.202344000000039, + -3.202803000000131, + -2.7081140000000232, + -2.2271760000000995, + -1.8034299999999348, + -1.7431679999999687, + -1.942113000000063, + -2.21947299999988, + -2.2729930000000422, + -2.292607999999973, + -2.7399189999998725, + -2.856551999999965, + -3.0905170000000908, + -3.221170000000029, + -2.35020099999997, + -1.7180230000001302, + -1.3601099999998496, + -0.742038999999977, + -1.1661280000000716, + -1.161811999999827, + -1.394367000000102, + -1.2706640000001244, + 2.01519200000007, + 24.425326999999925, + 9.304266999999982, + 7.951520000000073, + 6.250230999999985, + -22.69619899999998, + -8.698601000000053, + -8.708133999999973, + -10.79838000000018, + -4.60545100000013, + -3.0339359999998123, + -1.9256040000000212, + -0.9738119999999526, + -0.4587789999998222, + -0.11783000000013999, + 0.4640420000000631, + -0.20495299999993222, + -0.7828700000000026, + -1.201609999999846, + -1.9557280000001356, + -1.8020320000000538 + ] } }, { "horizon": 5, "variables_beating_random_walk": 3, + "n_origins": 49, "relative_rmse_by_variable": { "world_gdp": 0.8751391076936442, "world_cpi": 0.6930722652538598, @@ -173,11 +3589,852 @@ "cpisa": 4.662216796538033, "cpi_energy": 16.15754259685054, "uk_gdp": 6.382838423062953 + }, + "dm_stat_by_variable": { + "world_gdp": -1.007369319410086, + "world_cpi": -2.0251841694908155, + "oil_price": 0.7163150844714677, + "bank_rate": 1.0410632936098354, + "eri": 1.864632893843481, + "cpisa": -1.8356889237587806, + "cpi_energy": 0.6928077563473743, + "uk_gdp": 0.7645242496371848 + }, + "dm_pvalue_by_variable": { + "world_gdp": 0.3188087316282142, + "world_cpi": 0.04842909860969242, + "oil_price": 0.4772675908612657, + "bank_rate": 0.30306166369472753, + "eri": 0.0683534598600873, + "cpisa": 0.07260263870798363, + "cpi_energy": 0.49176875146373766, + "uk_gdp": 0.448297237642005 + }, + "bvar_errors_by_origin": { + "world_gdp": [ + 1.1842679514792849, + 0.5135718455319989, + 0.1851809090699703, + -0.7716551840431976, + -1.2251852642826861, + -0.8111673757577478, + -0.6738125115853109, + -0.9926337015340323, + -1.0432100263948314, + -0.9006789583846739, + -0.5025120901656237, + -0.4012802900471115, + 0.8074588585550373, + 0.5646716587177139, + 0.4020806535853012, + 0.2598733969638829, + 0.28973745138875984, + -0.5546035196561547, + -1.2387354175090763, + -0.7556395536323066, + -0.48690551421549344, + 0.0803828905132491, + 0.402761304446301, + 0.542508941342362, + 0.02580581676835436, + -0.004023355233641723, + 0.02371676994579275, + 2.966185526725667, + 13.703558331386716, + 5.047084092863599, + 4.841874701499137, + 3.862694001390821, + -1.5194708423834413, + -15.873842989264688, + -4.246239971757404, + -3.2905492137730903, + -3.015939603473612, + -2.0557856062484348, + -0.7702600171998597, + -0.17904578842393448, + -0.3571807489794878, + -0.6229832159791613, + -0.08739335268262494, + -0.20301227866815452, + -0.3045838624798307, + -0.40195319319383316, + -0.5256709540803968, + -0.7880503667878997, + -0.7171361820786046 + ], + "world_cpi": [ + 0.3815517554579628, + 1.1991228192742938, + 0.805633526522854, + 1.468367932336946, + 0.887713282895163, + 1.6096500421668338, + 1.5907996060299752, + 2.489668673023857, + 1.2379932311608854, + 2.1202502173691187, + 1.8385849953698994, + 2.2684425976682974, + 0.26251662263604203, + 1.6409243584367346, + 0.8095602336850902, + 0.5280924920323855, + -1.052890999263525, + 0.27834838055719047, + -0.19074274533141988, + 0.1321512817357302, + -0.8157145914523767, + -0.42992710134586787, + -0.6252463284509986, + 0.25101799190827023, + -0.9222524662416731, + 0.2256019846270192, + 0.13368137760619447, + 0.4573163910989706, + 0.09160784003324807, + 1.3472770116774768, + 1.307292946235009, + 0.8647213503371631, + -1.0450309664526571, + -2.034176225984538, + -2.9485732924368904, + -4.910238988607773, + -6.678350356062651, + -6.719761572450182, + -7.64782524415989, + -6.260175864351368, + -5.059163489362788, + -2.0546176648148844, + -1.0332298673544642, + 0.6159592384319694, + -0.6313634012556122, + 0.45375088189382495, + 0.5202906836830152, + 0.08154086846548125, + -0.3307272955422036 + ], + "oil_price": [ + 34.544428632322195, + 18.48629865438022, + 24.73011829958824, + 21.7758455476515, + 27.597372331294025, + 27.225797110230076, + 55.6505525380432, + 77.38431109097809, + 59.960894198141546, + 83.42112441320762, + 88.07483231035235, + 80.57850355080046, + 21.708140837902874, + 27.679266192704404, + -11.945176756859667, + -29.475363364346492, + -35.94911693684395, + -3.2513360238278324, + -9.448757894354003, + -0.27082452763119136, + -10.037850602234187, + -27.3592093242313, + -16.936907965892715, + 4.087292503565834, + -2.2063445794825043, + 17.294959063297426, + 23.845854146762406, + 33.467597520483366, + 66.8070293581747, + 51.52487280116242, + 43.77709753915991, + 14.247537987519934, + -16.55293628035082, + -64.33138740532462, + -41.539009750737364, + -58.58603286259387, + -53.31440747677868, + -37.49736489331889, + -19.906076661344002, + -1.7496052979548722, + 25.33980117186337, + 31.479563952493038, + 18.572661413442916, + 1.3478377105273012, + -15.796104692711765, + -16.629999296103676, + 0.5496695474354851, + -0.31747042500722955, + 13.487611435485348 + ], + "bank_rate": [ + -0.1847759328842879, + -0.1852901920074207, + -0.10133329361546767, + -0.32435778298805035, + -0.4027157806427783, + -0.08070007678476548, + -0.01844836439630504, + 0.03842555012319804, + 0.05658524838584755, + 0.14035453438339096, + 0.12179558355246578, + 0.11413692328723735, + 0.32867631642413375, + 0.5602393632192322, + 0.5642154339363574, + 0.5922458474089982, + 0.5100477340891257, + 0.6046525629895048, + -0.069452568500947, + -0.16156882135680917, + -0.051323099754235935, + -0.13827944480535703, + -0.3269731617616647, + -0.10191998951212744, + -0.21535665268806548, + -0.25133602293352986, + -0.25975706997942744, + -0.01942331396562491, + 0.6643137928781833, + 0.6251058927165777, + 0.5014743242941099, + 0.6185660457766852, + -0.196284871021917, + -0.8104165063502383, + 0.2901665724270377, + -0.08732307132817413, + -0.5927830579429707, + -1.338153126535274, + -2.718436721071879, + -3.8453617241645945, + -4.093600064742613, + -4.414463227906037, + -3.8921539714671645, + -2.3380934220404166, + -1.4072257127527612, + -0.4900210781463681, + 0.3657344334980053, + 0.3535097369855187, + 0.6835527724854895 + ], + "eri": [ + -1.4720858887152986, + 1.4276359904476976, + 0.4035468246040068, + -3.3510114318690967, + -10.304140266561944, + -10.052537128128279, + -8.262662696938719, + -6.755675596986748, + -5.625733243048899, + -5.501007692029873, + -2.9235487235296205, + 2.846298365261191, + 9.23793862501907, + 18.081532073216522, + 24.00979972207284, + 22.894917759721636, + 14.709294086188436, + 13.077661331871923, + 0.6602361379368062, + -4.28087455615821, + -3.1349403805835436, + 0.2931216216252892, + -2.096213361188518, + -1.8794322498907263, + 0.23804730204437874, + 3.1915928383982077, + -3.8784722034856713, + -3.2195995441657033, + 1.620753191783308, + -0.22486308803144084, + -4.446584261046667, + -1.6772444507672049, + -4.594667176759742, + -6.137588469442335, + -4.610183524108095, + -4.985970685266807, + 0.5082970340111501, + 4.40295490073845, + 4.151823903910611, + 2.8814477179936375, + 0.45024248882594975, + -7.599061662466681, + -8.789212669327469, + -10.978378932556438, + -10.187255087801475, + -7.435700699875383, + -4.844362150157963, + -6.116656772719466, + -5.051398078681814 + ], + "cpisa": [ + 1.3522434987389715, + 0.47465734371178314, + 0.4133995110391311, + 1.2486388982241579, + 2.198034449289594, + 1.5810592906050829, + 2.1936473576877233, + 2.9095125493673777, + 3.510555677903767, + 2.981198765038357, + 3.066454605514707, + 2.80982548017721, + 2.204282176180243, + 1.4817048141414375, + 0.9901944937080316, + -0.023856402798685394, + -0.7183191935479272, + -1.3082795758150496, + -1.1740683668271004, + -1.0845348104991217, + -0.24007060847606, + -0.8860672640030316, + -0.5582998265596757, + 0.2170396920616895, + 0.5007458981637001, + 0.05176014710440313, + 0.9160804403306315, + 0.8216428346605653, + 1.446737840060905, + 1.3971411374337208, + 1.9398485493076691, + 1.3246220072855976, + 0.8720507364078003, + -2.0182501163588995, + -2.7280583840955046, + -4.511553992620065, + -7.058628260221383, + -8.35681056278861, + -9.637407329176142, + -8.21580537483868, + -7.949527704212073, + -3.5781977092188413, + -2.339094252449911, + 0.24032301077164675, + -0.06778076839827918, + 1.5917887505192425, + 0.7679769646530303, + -0.1704668529928881, + -0.5715658332208591 + ], + "cpi_energy": [ + 9.381516959113128, + 7.120677343414968, + 6.382663397938472, + 6.326294105117654, + 9.737607455376292, + 8.869559998298769, + 12.561324281714292, + 16.864705837003044, + 16.043436404339786, + 17.071049951588293, + 19.35867695852221, + 17.723364803095933, + 6.798078998008577, + 9.279214415057368, + 3.804533346099447, + -2.5740417570036698, + -7.004547797293753, + -2.239972681142831, + -3.0928941250776916, + -1.2488587179534534, + -1.5535220508073735, + -5.718212831168785, + -6.41802330329574, + 2.403240844633501, + -4.406849187633611, + -0.8521332062052807, + 5.567860727776974, + 7.148650792221247, + 8.034409478856446, + 14.683078349877633, + 16.976312551251795, + 9.925649108955781, + -0.22469657593217107, + -15.205831766051347, + -16.02623884055822, + -23.338362756133506, + -45.36463494153452, + -39.500021169899696, + -44.473599778516245, + -29.537768336115846, + -22.148950184537057, + 21.22815618825473, + 21.103938554080173, + 29.53670938122582, + 24.952501124589276, + 26.193168877739936, + 12.740748114856956, + 6.9920610170626105, + 7.068054259319297 + ], + "uk_gdp": [ + -0.8520865042435162, + -1.6775367984751028, + -0.8515911027104721, + -2.2838141727268066, + -3.07659047503671, + -2.59352673084868, + -2.36022820631365, + -1.7916829820449038, + -1.2626269684603812, + -0.49066083554089346, + -0.08183764269006133, + 0.4612717978170622, + 0.6962461618875295, + 0.35408423802709876, + 0.33249560683225354, + 0.22902615807129223, + 0.03166204797548744, + -0.33443595606172494, + -1.1400880852127102, + -0.6594534500923146, + 0.21825753307052764, + 1.0339895488211823, + 1.5171071519737325, + 1.599901155110274, + 1.1057573193727421, + 0.4927100012621395, + 0.5048222400025679, + 3.5381896740714183, + 26.729993348310927, + 10.852254537070166, + 10.094911725671636, + 11.312193539502687, + 0.6695442147490667, + -30.654021161825995, + -9.826707746074362, + -8.064207101347165, + -10.042820250535897, + -3.5061094015941308, + -1.9723381139044704, + -0.7796846645410369, + 0.06125557002997084, + -0.1572569472646137, + 0.37525795417536756, + -0.19683945871020114, + -0.6115177263459373, + -0.6503138362884329, + -1.564790483030265, + -2.6476384359473286, + -1.862595765486276 + ] + }, + "random_walk_errors_by_origin": { + "world_gdp": [ + -1.018747000000019, + -1.5744770000000017, + -1.9635920000000056, + -2.483795999999984, + -2.805953000000045, + -2.878783999999996, + -2.831950000000006, + -3.253700999999978, + -3.3737770000000182, + -3.331250999999952, + -3.0787109999999984, + -3.1839009999999917, + -2.5941930000000184, + -2.6654869999999846, + -2.946947000000023, + -3.2311860000000365, + -3.3218369999999595, + -3.838032999999996, + -4.138031000000012, + -3.6902580000000285, + -3.527441999999951, + -3.129918000000032, + -2.7887830000000235, + -2.603072999999995, + -2.80318299999999, + -2.6766360000000304, + -2.3885520000000042, + 0.4608470000000011, + 10.838919999999973, + 2.3869569999999953, + 2.2056539999999814, + 1.179992000000027, + -3.142426999999998, + -14.242779999999982, + -6.190367999999978, + -5.968124999999986, + -5.635974000000033, + -4.242817000000002, + -3.0239970000000085, + -2.2899570000000153, + -2.2299580000000105, + -1.8307269999999676, + -1.4668550000000096, + -1.4943460000000073, + -1.6389499999999657, + -1.8189009999999826, + -1.8119480000000294, + -1.9585609999999747, + -1.9072770000000219 + ], + "world_cpi": [ + -2.3262830000000463, + -1.5181989999999814, + -1.868302999999969, + -1.141098999999997, + -1.6682380000000308, + -0.9882839999999646, + -0.9589000000000283, + 0.024566999999990458, + -1.1068769999999972, + -0.3122929999999542, + -0.44933900000000904, + 0.1432399999999916, + -1.5357490000000098, + -0.4557100000000105, + -1.0767130000000407, + -1.2975359999999796, + -2.638525999999956, + -1.6381099999999833, + -2.072862999999984, + -1.7693759999999656, + -2.6804240000000163, + -2.268546000000015, + -2.4662850000000276, + -1.656741000000011, + -2.7074630000000184, + -1.6793769999999881, + -1.808606999999995, + -1.3965319999999792, + -1.75217600000002, + -0.5360450000000014, + -0.5989720000000034, + -0.9380460000000426, + -2.398496000000023, + -3.067202000000009, + -4.718678000000011, + -6.560361, + -8.432965999999965, + -8.586629999999957, + -9.59690999999998, + -8.407755000000009, + -7.571444000000042, + -5.449085000000025, + -4.24745200000001, + -2.939955999999995, + -3.5442180000000008, + -2.697670999999957, + -2.391768000000013, + -2.589513000000011, + -3.002605000000017 + ], + "oil_price": [ + 14.31447300000002, + 0.07447199999995746, + 6.164934000000017, + 7.6678719999999885, + 12.423797999999977, + 10.968526999999995, + 40.06660500000004, + 63.715926999999965, + 47.178449, + 69.32923700000003, + 74.777444, + 67.63624999999996, + 9.758938999999998, + 14.07265700000005, + -21.477307999999994, + -39.69790599999999, + -45.58146599999998, + -16.232151999999985, + -22.21124900000001, + -12.224564000000044, + -19.06375300000002, + -34.93136400000003, + -25.510951999999975, + -3.002285000000029, + -7.599117999999976, + 11.600378999999975, + 20.24087800000001, + 30.183843999999965, + 60.93548400000003, + 47.17557199999999, + 39.02905400000003, + 10.343808000000024, + -19.789957999999956, + -64.81348500000001, + -51.686762999999985, + -68.37971399999998, + -60.56270999999998, + -41.016817, + -22.843927000000008, + -2.0041669999999954, + 26.863742000000002, + 36.01380399999999, + 28.675340000000006, + 20.399511000000018, + 4.533389, + 5.515152999999998, + 19.131102999999996, + 14.927001999999959, + 29.320311000000004 + ], + "bank_rate": [ + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.1577, + 0.25, + 0.25, + 0.25, + 0.25, + -0.06640000000000001, + -0.25, + -0.25, + -0.4102, + -0.5, + -0.3413, + -0.25, + -0.25, + -0.08979999999999999, + 0.13829999999999998, + 0.65, + 0.65, + 0.65, + 0.65, + 0.5117, + 0.0, + -0.02339999999999999, + -0.35629999999999995, + -0.8583000000000001, + -1.5171999999999999, + -2.7056, + -3.7321, + -4.002000000000001, + -4.201899999999999, + -3.6328, + -2.4444, + -1.3944999999999999, + -0.6301999999999994, + 0.3046999999999995, + 0.6508000000000003, + 0.9016000000000002 + ], + "eri": [ + 0.8099449999999706, + 2.3382419999999797, + 0.633418000000006, + -2.288072999999997, + -7.866759999999999, + -8.88820899999996, + -7.180222999999955, + -6.743945999999994, + -6.349648000000002, + -6.616706999999963, + -4.5881030000000464, + 0.37547499999999445, + 4.4344919999999775, + 14.575338000000045, + 19.292309999999986, + 17.89255400000002, + 10.942857000000004, + 11.055658999999991, + 1.4216270000000009, + -3.1647330000000125, + -2.6247900000000186, + 0.1755459999999971, + -1.5947320000000218, + -1.3380960000000073, + 0.8153320000000122, + 4.294291000000044, + -2.035107000000039, + -1.8387819999999806, + 1.7150279999999611, + 1.1777419999999665, + -2.80901700000004, + -1.31283499999995, + -3.183538999999996, + -5.494484, + -5.244408999999962, + -5.5262500000000045, + 0.3379139999999552, + 4.5502010000000155, + 4.615170000000035, + 4.31566399999997, + 2.337244000000055, + -2.5022089999999935, + -3.8306590000000256, + -5.592244999999991, + -5.935925999999995, + -4.705461000000014, + -2.8667159999999967, + -3.4611779999999612, + -3.4417150000000447 + ], + "cpisa": [ + -2.7387659999999983, + -3.2807770000000005, + -3.270945999999981, + -2.619058999999993, + -1.7522739999999999, + -2.0786150000000134, + -1.468952999999999, + -0.6506899999999973, + 0.040210000000001855, + -0.3651289999999676, + -0.12693500000000313, + -0.08287699999999631, + -0.19179500000001326, + -1.0948390000000359, + -1.2829619999999977, + -2.1301939999999604, + -2.5757050000000277, + -3.5325409999999806, + -3.563159999999982, + -3.6171679999999924, + -2.8230050000000233, + -3.290499000000011, + -3.0309760000000097, + -2.4691159999999854, + -2.145539000000042, + -2.7293339999999944, + -1.947654, + -1.873215000000016, + -0.994956000000002, + -1.3443919999999707, + -0.6968289999999797, + -1.1235059999999635, + -1.3595379999999864, + -3.383162000000027, + -4.857128999999986, + -6.555082000000027, + -9.472562000000039, + -10.912837000000025, + -12.352491999999984, + -11.473851000000025, + -11.560416999999973, + -8.654359999999997, + -6.888787999999977, + -4.749282999999991, + -3.956386000000009, + -2.5865200000000073, + -2.836185999999998, + -3.4355219999999917, + -3.896361000000013 + ], + "cpi_energy": [ + -2.388604999999984, + -3.3485920000000533, + -3.380963999999949, + -3.012654999999995, + -0.01596099999994749, + -0.3721740000000864, + 3.3425039999999626, + 8.543358000000012, + 7.93600200000003, + 9.077726999999982, + 12.022436000000084, + 12.023112000000083, + 3.5462440000000015, + 3.959218999999962, + 0.3339449999999715, + -5.042068000000086, + -8.061945000000037, + -6.061341000000084, + -6.937018999999964, + -5.756049999999959, + -6.106113999999934, + -9.420344999999998, + -10.206477999999947, + -2.311054000000013, + -8.47322900000006, + -5.795493000000079, + 0.4506939999999986, + 2.6486260000000357, + 4.7325009999999565, + 9.622602000000029, + 12.563206000000037, + 6.432628000000022, + -1.4452810000000227, + -11.635119999999915, + -18.65445299999999, + -25.13144299999999, + -48.71747400000004, + -43.65754800000002, + -48.79946200000006, + -35.82032300000003, + -29.16976699999998, + 5.137576999999965, + 9.637652000000003, + 17.217712000000006, + 18.335274000000027, + 21.130083000000013, + 11.473911000000044, + 6.987974000000008, + 6.802098000000001 + ], + "uk_gdp": [ + -1.7612919999999122, + -2.577502999999979, + -2.203836999999794, + -3.146199999999908, + -3.8177009999999427, + -3.9655250000000706, + -3.8600770000000466, + -3.5059980000000905, + -3.1636250000001382, + -2.614166999999952, + -2.400900999999976, + -2.2453080000000227, + -2.674983999999995, + -2.659983999999895, + -2.8900790000000143, + -3.2420589999999265, + -3.589422999999897, + -3.5310280000001057, + -3.8382560000000012, + -3.2996519999999236, + -2.5675270000001547, + -2.0345859999999902, + -1.4897779999998875, + -1.244609999999966, + -1.3791380000000117, + -1.710929999999962, + -1.4003320000001622, + 1.512621000000081, + 24.212316999999985, + 8.755148999999847, + 7.945555000000013, + 9.03351600000019, + -0.4990740000000642, + -24.36877900000013, + -10.066845999999941, + -9.716384000000062, + -11.35475600000018, + -4.706515999999965, + -3.293848999999909, + -1.9820620000000417, + -1.0151549999998224, + -0.21889499999997497, + 0.20412899999996625, + -0.26141099999995276, + -0.8242129999998724, + -0.9617259999999987, + -1.6337690000000293, + -2.5274850000000697, + -1.9577739999999721 + ] } }, { "horizon": 6, "variables_beating_random_walk": 3, + "n_origins": 49, "relative_rmse_by_variable": { "world_gdp": 0.8127438220907905, "world_cpi": 0.688146308068257, @@ -207,11 +4464,852 @@ "cpisa": 5.509931242453259, "cpi_energy": 18.061855549902738, "uk_gdp": 6.6489562769496535 + }, + "dm_stat_by_variable": { + "world_gdp": -1.4265516327654535, + "world_cpi": -1.9237494231810355, + "oil_price": 0.5839940855282598, + "bank_rate": 0.8838471782754933, + "eri": 1.985821168443455, + "cpisa": -1.751029815828748, + "cpi_energy": 0.8809971128111708, + "uk_gdp": 0.6323493449527252 + }, + "dm_pvalue_by_variable": { + "world_gdp": 0.1601815621112085, + "world_cpi": 0.060327152956561096, + "oil_price": 0.5619588768547082, + "bank_rate": 0.3811843952762858, + "eri": 0.052780844554950634, + "cpisa": 0.08632940391234668, + "cpi_energy": 0.38270953545259934, + "uk_gdp": 0.5301593986873689 + }, + "bvar_errors_by_origin": { + "world_gdp": [ + 0.976152847903677, + 0.38545132821684547, + 0.10061566385780907, + -0.9950279755256588, + -1.6705134725726793, + -0.9872460082119119, + -1.2446340905233342, + -1.1760050819059416, + -1.1662319832363437, + -1.006749333384107, + -0.7032810447223596, + -0.2171603842988361, + 0.8062692988896174, + 0.3365252028247596, + 0.2691293694936121, + 0.21822440912694674, + 0.17851964574259682, + -0.8744177679618019, + -0.9959117547899154, + -0.8129887331077157, + -0.25432993348488253, + 0.17649243492093092, + 0.2656089388567011, + 0.5569087425262751, + 0.07953503135064466, + 0.46308182197560654, + 2.850674260221979, + 13.109677715341434, + 5.243103384266988, + 4.878606662631, + 4.308086516061337, + 2.4191683551220535, + -2.4489397505307693, + -16.526571273971285, + -4.1914571793580535, + -3.4914535463557286, + -3.1248585275740766, + -1.8291864991330158, + -0.4986203305317076, + -0.10534517222805562, + -0.3065374923270383, + -0.5662278300067101, + -0.0558916287862985, + -0.2807321091031554, + -0.5936242229250865, + -0.4303310204836066, + -0.6509501344723958, + -0.7647055394192535, + -0.9186414656422244 + ], + "world_cpi": [ + 0.8444175267898117, + 1.3728238065125424, + 1.305643347238913, + 1.329724894586434, + 1.5546724642770755, + 2.0796346084348443, + 2.6920992428005093, + 1.819412242296039, + 1.8299853551070555, + 2.616441629556846, + 2.837331971241838, + 1.624479111890878, + 0.5743220458732594, + 1.569612099616677, + 1.0034258468002122, + 0.11460584493994475, + -0.796076320632551, + 0.1454048673562056, + -0.02233424984871135, + -0.6133998160841543, + -0.8325336053561614, + -0.3276691999685113, + 0.03415717442891264, + -0.6160340523755963, + -0.6422968332790902, + 0.10186723819623467, + 0.6599173083160395, + 0.7780032633028782, + 0.43582203009555087, + 1.5849329008302675, + 0.8336805176837174, + -0.07586242122368958, + -1.43863635425015, + -3.4261524325686423, + -4.604136248251052, + -7.304785961761638, + -7.801718173656468, + -8.08792540654997, + -7.760942785604357, + -7.01114065795764, + -5.213620160093171, + -1.8126711933365414, + -0.9294810674566065, + 0.11480444524107725, + -0.3798195689803947, + 0.7592668023423812, + 0.6353161888335421, + -0.20692865527041704, + -0.23171569920276625 + ], + "oil_price": [ + 33.149450025514284, + 27.252959873686166, + 31.862869328567456, + 24.83669481708739, + 37.19949686092082, + 53.69324447965266, + 87.12020238259095, + 67.10482023158039, + 84.20600714240504, + 97.34336078275277, + 106.78354071428879, + 53.76379062633066, + 15.500037302977546, + 15.999031412321187, + -16.333807764426865, + -16.823375783405027, + -33.84052816919882, + -15.817794384743593, + -11.104253325091065, + -11.736843282113341, + -13.553348819463508, + -15.912914010481927, + -7.118755268871098, + -2.8079005726435184, + 5.071429812383883, + 21.90015657217856, + 44.60326060408272, + 73.50022419759443, + 45.9593009955604, + 50.260837900826516, + 19.70870193018061, + 4.992184900355426, + -20.59867344832452, + -70.44938854739962, + -58.77341657501984, + -74.28899556298711, + -42.878579846042555, + -24.274447561961438, + -6.760825193521043, + 9.187141669310165, + 17.371701241276696, + 32.66405419979782, + 21.55676233937504, + -4.386096104112767, + -7.141504506675005, + -13.994946228456172, + -4.6949721531278215, + 15.47123386931014, + 10.930356552934882 + ], + "bank_rate": [ + -0.25961217670229025, + -0.24327101315442895, + -0.1557669173494488, + -0.37390115209094893, + -0.45977845875744155, + -0.12384743596961617, + -0.06689624522795135, + 0.0013849906636498321, + 0.02681215004402482, + 0.10895510993776036, + 0.10214272439643257, + 0.13003996256010564, + 0.5465217643321152, + 0.6829062160094417, + 0.6318034211686729, + 0.6734830270196354, + 0.6099370785839671, + 0.49536848313650067, + -0.12184560626032404, + -0.13981544481226305, + -0.19627459635504524, + -0.1986867054353999, + -0.2995425074476674, + -0.09809674499087206, + -0.21400540558659542, + -0.2697392910369721, + -0.14799260518414858, + 0.4776849588490971, + 0.661764255112098, + 0.6046698957505013, + 0.49256382562795287, + 0.6171085428754198, + -0.1593075800752304, + -0.7575360453139508, + -0.01466638592615932, + -0.5618285429822998, + -1.250418948488933, + -2.5356231345183478, + -3.7813997076765067, + -4.473477963374961, + -4.847675716989642, + -4.597495453261743, + -3.976698540021582, + -2.414695506572476, + -1.3105255663625073, + -0.29755733117392236, + 0.5821083836134324, + 0.556294921620383, + 0.8898241043455943 + ], + "eri": [ + -2.9919224215267377, + -1.7196978800142801, + -2.239669131088533, + -5.1217551982697955, + -12.056148920738337, + -9.64144199398089, + -11.054543002168373, + -8.952046662563816, + -7.505633299237047, + -4.770155298031682, + 2.9488213379025296, + 4.807175559977281, + 18.00649865234186, + 21.443363676813306, + 24.151022246427715, + 22.55012177047496, + 17.18021768916941, + 11.89859235245359, + -1.0393578535455958, + -4.5449752932031515, + -1.659876205702119, + 0.2402025122206055, + -3.460118176687047, + -1.5971765548677013, + 3.482246928539496, + -1.708048985613516, + -3.936478658713213, + -1.1284202458519985, + 1.388898441715014, + -1.0775785117366468, + -7.923326455276367, + -3.465781468434443, + -4.542210169007149, + -5.727566711023542, + -5.527563077345292, + -2.331926051926132, + 3.0254099130824557, + 4.4279330777577, + 3.9579030461372895, + -0.12981646068755026, + -1.98933843640566, + -6.973090335397217, + -11.121647078599153, + -12.230113777508734, + -12.54972634361252, + -8.307342639676222, + -4.651098423672181, + -8.26595087590266, + -4.8544585070251856 + ], + "cpisa": [ + 1.560371220024706, + 0.6852195191942201, + 0.6281436612175071, + 2.0450340734495285, + 2.673644237814244, + 2.30352472724212, + 3.1954587116649122, + 3.7801203667467576, + 3.8263186388692816, + 3.5733546803485297, + 3.744150388233095, + 3.556818072234023, + 1.9691915658137873, + 1.4250769296232306, + 0.5322417744591235, + -0.0021446961313813517, + -1.1300114296630568, + -1.6564693667339156, + -1.3462204565646516, + -0.7363539013023797, + -0.622318726631363, + -0.9510359336597389, + -0.2877774067756036, + 0.43251994083527734, + 0.30532743792628025, + 0.48366908720157653, + 0.9963295715443223, + 2.0119983954635927, + 1.304188933228204, + 1.8481477206354953, + 1.9274311116980698, + 1.116988114153628, + -0.0333462939626088, + -3.795884252401663, + -4.067943019745201, + -7.538653061457012, + -8.742251247138313, + -10.68620947039966, + -10.385144217739423, + -9.517118781648264, + -7.887264261831547, + -3.2330672106051566, + -2.28242344060169, + 0.5555312736651672, + 0.15408710203774945, + 1.5540241503084644, + 0.49778084338561257, + -0.6216061960337811, + -0.6906680551280147 + ], + "cpi_energy": [ + 11.149637556457037, + 10.054934747560878, + 7.207530148103501, + 8.735484395190383, + 12.013484033335317, + 13.813526915944408, + 20.341506133823373, + 16.75597559275377, + 19.27951306004502, + 21.840016189143853, + 23.92481472474924, + 16.46634268951823, + 6.358612613238051, + 8.283435151057006, + 2.4841867072016157, + -1.8454586170856828, + -7.098748842910368, + -3.7954120307540506, + -3.2479004975709813, + -2.9899138231920688, + -3.966820818050678, + -6.250972295393353, + -0.010371952296281961, + -3.7567121465940545, + -3.4211823111763806, + 3.0589196347447114, + 7.434772888346856, + 15.827618349792715, + 6.697458543544599, + 18.72243541215346, + 14.738122751265792, + 3.742118190977635, + -2.0581292984551283, + -24.241234003319732, + -18.923286698096717, + -49.67518710073432, + -46.72920762320177, + -46.39030497688782, + -39.88996646371129, + -25.317303929313198, + -13.532801708625016, + 25.613983027516724, + 22.707875966412644, + 36.24453429632479, + 32.24774689336516, + 25.04815423577577, + 11.130104296412696, + 6.9380393775576295, + 9.204954209851621 + ], + "uk_gdp": [ + -1.52338775986982, + -2.2156392951087582, + -1.4723408858378662, + -3.055580546819783, + -3.7475565257157086, + -3.0487620808976317, + -2.455387395548769, + -1.990544044257149, + -1.3518291886605311, + -0.7709123884728797, + -0.21668098280133563, + 0.20861734541813348, + 0.8595679087186454, + 0.2586944500694699, + 0.008020210034146658, + 0.05258738982684008, + 0.0935647341780168, + -0.485988846091459, + -0.6537586763047329, + -0.3583104561230357, + 0.4180203213390996, + 1.4788490352448207, + 1.5904448424316797, + 1.8991349160123718, + 1.0456011002822834, + 0.9096886232748602, + 3.6849370943457416, + 26.16181721826206, + 11.522089365379543, + 9.90450428107647, + 11.619939701837666, + 5.0159701671568655, + -0.5369665287178123, + -32.1961135017807, + -10.536433119508729, + -8.259250860543034, + -9.91229166754033, + -3.432590998683281, + -1.6833773744922382, + -0.496832780663226, + 0.5274092884430956, + 0.23213604268335075, + -0.24919587909539587, + -0.7328903125678607, + -0.6875141765751778, + -0.9666084489440436, + -2.1147500736310576, + -2.7885641191955983, + -1.8618427147353032 + ] + }, + "random_walk_errors_by_origin": { + "world_gdp": [ + -1.6051930000000425, + -2.0829259999999863, + -2.413936999999976, + -3.0533230000000344, + -3.569970000000012, + -3.4183960000000297, + -3.762149999999963, + -3.8241219999999885, + -3.9007780000000025, + -3.8427279999999655, + -3.7235130000000254, + -3.524392999999975, + -3.235907999999995, + -3.473948000000007, + -3.74266300000005, + -3.9666389999999865, + -4.178524999999979, + -4.779745999999989, + -4.498719000000051, + -4.323157999999978, + -3.865370999999982, + -3.645471000000043, + -3.544785999999988, + -3.1638710000000287, + -3.30953599999998, + -2.7264810000000352, + -0.054706000000010135, + 10.082917000000009, + 1.8261589999999615, + 1.6993009999999913, + 1.1301470000000222, + -0.8085810000000038, + -4.620709999999974, + -15.20312899999999, + -6.65578099999999, + -6.711480999999992, + -6.231390000000033, + -4.502279999999985, + -3.2503060000000232, + -2.695371000000023, + -2.5740829999999733, + -2.0622710000000097, + -1.7538089999999897, + -1.8652589999999805, + -2.22431499999999, + -2.156072999999992, + -2.190105000000017, + -2.194231000000002, + -2.3826219999999694 + ], + "world_cpi": [ + -2.3994050000000016, + -1.8959859999999935, + -1.894331999999963, + -1.8090180000000373, + -1.5116649999999936, + -1.0320219999999836, + -0.35322000000002163, + -1.1329059999999913, + -0.9802119999999945, + -0.2927659999999719, + 0.09950199999997267, + -0.9300690000000031, + -1.6131829999999923, + -0.950048000000038, + -1.2780089999999973, + -2.0896849999999745, + -2.711418999999978, + -2.1502969999999664, + -2.263713999999993, + -2.881719999999973, + -3.0606950000000097, + -2.5391780000000495, + -2.168927999999994, + -2.8983140000000276, + -2.7917209999999955, + -2.1888779999999883, + -1.6671640000000139, + -1.4548189999999863, + -1.7776180000000181, + -0.6832299999999805, + -1.4475470000000428, + -2.2570530000000417, + -3.125489000000016, + -4.744120000000009, + -6.707545999999979, + -9.281541000000004, + -9.905636999999956, + -10.323902999999973, + -10.08467300000001, + -9.56031200000001, + -8.170265000000029, + -5.720123000000001, + -4.677229000000011, + -4.03198100000003, + -3.8502279999999587, + -2.990589, + -2.8605509999999867, + -3.4323820000000183, + -3.453339000000028 + ], + "oil_price": [ + 9.176717999999994, + 5.534406999999987, + 10.238704999999982, + 7.6814919999999915, + 18.982754, + 34.92885000000001, + 69.175862, + 51.252219999999966, + 69.34285700000004, + 81.33640000000003, + 91.59657299999998, + 38.868195999999955, + 1.6089500000000498, + 0.6871000000000436, + -27.690742999999998, + -28.762337000000002, + -45.00020599999999, + -30.361237999999958, + -25.61012100000005, + -25.277188000000024, + -23.995795000000044, + -24.92969199999999, + -17.131371, + -10.997990000000016, + -1.452245000000005, + 15.308835999999985, + 40.18551600000001, + 69.315065, + 39.179867, + 45.175927, + 14.052265000000034, + 0.15468000000004167, + -25.682263999999975, + -73.44238000000001, + -70.37935899999997, + -85.53949899999998, + -51.205944999999986, + -28.736233000000027, + -10.633061999999995, + 8.171146000000022, + 18.854018999999994, + 38.032105, + 32.680094999999994, + 16.744254000000012, + 15.690466000000015, + 11.121379999999988, + 16.945302999999967, + 33.32506599999999, + 29.301785999999993 + ], + "bank_rate": [ + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.1577, + 0.25, + 0.25, + 0.25, + 0.25, + 0.09129999999999999, + -0.1577, + -0.25, + -0.4102, + -0.5, + -0.5, + -0.3413, + -0.25, + -0.25, + 0.04849999999999999, + 0.65, + 0.65, + 0.65, + 0.65, + 0.65, + 0.5117, + -0.02339999999999999, + -0.35629999999999995, + -0.8583000000000001, + -1.5171999999999999, + -2.7056, + -3.7555, + -4.3349, + -4.7039, + -4.2917, + -3.6328, + -2.4444, + -1.2329999999999997, + -0.3971999999999998, + 0.5609999999999999, + 0.9016000000000002, + 1.1462000000000003 + ], + "eri": [ + -0.07376600000003464, + -0.47425299999997605, + -1.7466530000000375, + -3.835831999999982, + -9.13093299999997, + -8.06393399999996, + -9.55644099999995, + -8.729719000000046, + -8.164465999999948, + -5.852276000000018, + 1.1997499999999945, + 2.058273999999983, + 12.589564999999993, + 17.47749200000004, + 18.656984999999963, + 16.730710000000045, + 12.73845799999998, + 9.576700000000017, + -0.26257900000001655, + -3.2601150000000416, + -0.9862979999999766, + 0.20086899999995467, + -2.817054999999982, + -0.8688740000000053, + 4.198909000000015, + -0.39661499999999705, + -1.813459000000023, + 0.49270500000000084, + 1.6469639999999686, + 0.5745599999999627, + -6.003740999999991, + -2.96189099999998, + -3.1629970000000185, + -5.3124729999999545, + -6.129432000000008, + -2.856809999999996, + 2.9011449999999854, + 4.635712000000012, + 4.497675000000015, + 1.4522210000000086, + 0.16723100000001523, + -1.2674279999999953, + -5.5067339999999945, + -6.053421000000014, + -7.568903999999975, + -5.036729000000037, + -2.226396999999963, + -5.117790000000014, + -2.9120430000000397 + ], + "cpisa": [ + -3.3756119999999896, + -3.847467999999992, + -3.8210829999999874, + -2.6121540000000323, + -2.0841199999999844, + -2.1057989999999904, + -1.217380999999989, + -0.5099270000000047, + -0.358224000000007, + -0.45878099999998767, + -0.11006099999997332, + 0.05977699999999686, + -0.9540760000000432, + -1.6813960000000066, + -2.2238459999999804, + -2.558830999999998, + -3.3898869999999874, + -4.325441000000012, + -4.203724999999963, + -3.763889000000006, + -3.7191360000000486, + -3.8451579999999694, + -3.262016000000017, + -2.786104000000023, + -2.876055000000008, + -2.8437850000000253, + -2.4278739999999743, + -1.2259960000000092, + -1.6613800000000083, + -1.4273449999999457, + -1.2379569999999944, + -1.8397579999999607, + -2.73594300000002, + -5.523552999999993, + -6.638035000000002, + -10.013690000000054, + -11.629089000000022, + -13.728897000000018, + -13.61424199999999, + -13.341322999999988, + -12.112968000000023, + -9.04531499999996, + -7.565342999999984, + -5.218136000000015, + -4.453991999999971, + -3.3887370000000487, + -3.8264769999999544, + -4.572916000000021, + -4.69905399999999 + ], + "cpi_energy": [ + -3.02646500000003, + -2.5933330000000296, + -4.562956999999983, + -2.5684589999999616, + 0.232262999999989, + 2.7046439999999166, + 9.298617000000036, + 6.754008999999996, + 9.521923000000015, + 12.27066000000002, + 15.099930000000086, + 9.502357000000075, + 2.1698699999999462, + 1.9198659999999563, + -1.8491350000000466, + -4.9844510000000355, + -8.582096000000092, + -8.31339300000002, + -7.795402999999965, + -8.289193999999952, + -9.362727999999947, + -10.726629000000003, + -4.563105999999948, + -9.331613000000061, + -8.328637000000072, + -2.8059200000000146, + 1.3423420000000306, + 10.375872999999956, + 2.6020429999999806, + 12.707798000000025, + 9.422201000000086, + -0.5536329999999907, + -3.907872999999995, + -20.784910999999965, + -22.046246999999994, + -51.85847899999999, + -50.64380900000003, + -51.262054000000035, + -44.97011400000008, + -32.56156099999998, + -21.589459000000033, + 7.711317000000008, + 9.613205999999991, + 22.16462200000001, + 24.38884500000006, + 19.05421899999999, + 9.561714000000052, + 6.777651999999989, + 8.784295000000043 + ], + "uk_gdp": [ + -2.5244729999999436, + -3.2347769999998945, + -3.0017209999998613, + -4.082648999999947, + -4.62843799999996, + -4.623258000000078, + -4.163272000000006, + -3.9615090000002056, + -3.550615999999991, + -3.2116379999999936, + -2.90304100000003, + -2.9781789999999546, + -3.11549500000001, + -3.277069999999867, + -3.839529999999968, + -4.091562999999951, + -4.263899000000038, + -4.278767000000016, + -3.9167379999998957, + -3.5169780000001083, + -2.8840900000000147, + -2.164254000000028, + -1.9923489999998765, + -1.4576199999999062, + -1.9282560000001467, + -1.7168950000000223, + 1.3829530000000432, + 23.709745999999996, + 8.542138999999906, + 7.396436999999878, + 9.02755100000013, + 2.284211000000141, + -2.171654000000217, + -25.73702400000002, + -11.07509600000003, + -10.272760000000062, + -11.455821000000014, + -4.966429000000062, + -3.3503069999999298, + -2.0234049999999115, + -0.7752709999999752, + 0.10306400000013127, + -0.5213240000000496, + -0.880670999999893, + -1.0030689999998685, + -1.3938850000001821, + -2.2055259999999635, + -2.683226999999988, + -2.032717000000048 + ] } }, { "horizon": 7, "variables_beating_random_walk": 3, + "n_origins": 49, "relative_rmse_by_variable": { "world_gdp": 0.7541096873945587, "world_cpi": 0.6834302533007695, @@ -241,11 +5339,852 @@ "cpisa": 6.316217269665477, "cpi_energy": 19.43053130204883, "uk_gdp": 6.881862319253502 + }, + "dm_stat_by_variable": { + "world_gdp": -1.7554258126746471, + "world_cpi": -1.8493289916537627, + "oil_price": 0.5328840162632779, + "bank_rate": 0.7974420028619215, + "eri": 2.1071676894247577, + "cpisa": -1.6845587786494973, + "cpi_energy": 0.9774253430603028, + "uk_gdp": 0.5151915569572737 + }, + "dm_pvalue_by_variable": { + "world_gdp": 0.08556681614128708, + "world_cpi": 0.07057315916118698, + "oil_price": 0.5965725039360985, + "bank_rate": 0.4291216691711608, + "eri": 0.04035347053102284, + "cpisa": 0.09856620592852638, + "cpi_energy": 0.3332592779464879, + "uk_gdp": 0.6087837932023202 + }, + "bvar_errors_by_origin": { + "world_gdp": [ + 0.8352812963735801, + 0.305197345618069, + -0.11409292999076115, + -1.4210931221126657, + -1.8996572185343439, + -1.5634606514346956, + -1.464826940370699, + -1.3249778092156816, + -1.28279841386086, + -1.2553375706639827, + -0.6093156165035793, + -0.34478726360515566, + 0.6239063553007895, + 0.11041207703539158, + 0.18523473891002595, + 0.04387289139731365, + -0.028048834569858627, + -0.6219722786391912, + -1.0309735254281804, + -0.5815446381957372, + -0.2063846044139268, + 0.0241322810895781, + 0.3163978125056701, + 0.6195950755721924, + 0.5853371027141634, + 3.311217600248824, + 12.965302870347614, + 4.6164539871954275, + 5.101988693954013, + 4.32074417462735, + 2.859035578347914, + 1.4818927901935695, + -2.8605936719552574, + -16.678737198522924, + -4.421493858388203, + -3.551391632293303, + -2.902604554276877, + -1.5730497940639907, + -0.40935515736538264, + 0.028433367954846744, + -0.14030286851192386, + -0.5549551185796986, + -0.09957445755009076, + -0.5610703870465841, + -0.6224100469083282, + -0.4872944213429946, + -0.6209637509825257, + -0.9690360853438733, + -0.8042057536766265 + ], + "world_cpi": [ + 1.0025763312035565, + 1.898614552913216, + 1.1633555817472825, + 2.0161311868655503, + 2.0214999609043502, + 3.1985178877500857, + 2.0293052975769683, + 2.4323487290415073, + 2.313761185827161, + 3.640732960906689, + 2.212728305994233, + 1.9759396939572866, + 0.4698275645532135, + 1.7910626078997893, + 0.6075366336079355, + 0.4220976597206345, + -0.9752695926751471, + 0.33471756550125065, + -0.7741387544933218, + -0.626399352592955, + -0.7396107694581815, + 0.3429580634089575, + -0.8448877179652641, + -0.32624113474042815, + -0.7878321653553257, + 0.628256494688344, + 0.9856196568678683, + 1.130972911003937, + 0.6574899834353687, + 1.1203566468934127, + -0.11079833613894152, + -0.42483679470842617, + -2.7801107533552454, + -5.126283251395762, + -6.990934036730835, + -8.449715690877042, + -9.189678924084717, + -8.206986582356933, + -8.539384019715897, + -7.209058646441633, + -5.041462112769807, + -1.733977865814154, + -1.4904542465164923, + 0.3958397426544593, + -0.11480756389380531, + 0.8887427901646561, + 0.3771515647533761, + -0.10156923862348322, + -0.021342315123945355 + ], + "oil_price": [ + 42.326458985324734, + 34.58475050828963, + 34.888335764892076, + 34.38854566811659, + 64.16012250600693, + 85.2593143893597, + 76.97992720192087, + 91.40453137123836, + 98.23748139901062, + 116.02996467027333, + 79.84123198501612, + 47.46171019195498, + 3.9178467419999947, + 11.388394115147662, + -3.694756155425239, + -14.638680800891109, + -46.53912160039067, + -17.750703371301825, + -22.51298284210452, + -15.1691485149571, + -2.2114455665422383, + -6.174456413545215, + -13.758653641664353, + 4.386337575197331, + 9.856325460099981, + 42.7154589603316, + 84.53336659863328, + 52.613397657880796, + 44.82142401240998, + 26.000611223826127, + 10.390990322720086, + -0.014642307596830051, + -27.501399919754476, + -86.77331431562527, + -74.55591230881498, + -63.55721321132728, + -29.570745242169096, + -11.161037856911491, + 4.310808060524948, + 1.922052973648249, + 19.480993029735657, + 35.96147835367054, + 17.014727136794704, + 4.894603844878077, + -3.8477581634641638, + -18.94815757819805, + 10.839663332793691, + 13.011949510450563, + 15.14118904078606 + ], + "bank_rate": [ + -0.3392203455847254, + -0.3056161066701969, + -0.21547817257389879, + -0.42551462803511353, + -0.5187473901728823, + -0.17151988296607912, + -0.1198263482932535, + -0.040405763897491453, + -0.007969723445361176, + 0.07206654659049594, + 0.07649466096472834, + 0.29673735396472184, + 0.6884610549021739, + 0.7057034342434096, + 0.6915007371177965, + 0.7462986743648847, + 0.5435035063982676, + 0.4471616979602636, + -0.08590985412938423, + -0.2817254561372079, + -0.2752183261775546, + -0.1744975411938383, + -0.27657283199161015, + -0.09830237875729186, + -0.21499407919357927, + -0.15098486172971848, + 0.33789594624630115, + 0.4628220801404711, + 0.6553420950262915, + 0.5839208917898231, + 0.4830151038533397, + 0.613512620706461, + -0.14270943889338483, + -1.0134347796793237, + -0.4924796595512942, + -1.197094770469153, + -2.439658517941642, + -3.595622390732388, + -4.397882861070524, + -5.199778408691102, + -4.987256808271135, + -4.685336746187028, + -4.056547187932078, + -2.326504533707103, + -1.1371927732332998, + -0.07818674432842343, + 0.797346796254411, + 0.7585359742235376, + 0.9912244591882065 + ], + "eri": [ + -6.470426584608049, + -4.460506723582114, + -4.073750659662551, + -6.632009918478332, + -11.74405124849784, + -12.453375510413878, + -13.47523850200406, + -10.996365733594928, + -6.825460862983846, + 0.9671403416268163, + 4.695953014303996, + 13.210148988209482, + 21.475883684799044, + 21.235526006853206, + 23.721366166960024, + 25.117065553235363, + 16.336884125577, + 10.488235941444486, + -1.1662088116061682, + -3.088508281648785, + -1.8120461803137005, + -1.07745076532143, + -3.1477531653412143, + 1.5875488410543994, + -1.359155787520308, + -1.7019729646108885, + -1.8892334720626422, + -1.4442914544036398, + 0.6105292268271114, + -4.527427699663917, + -9.862566851776023, + -3.594842575118207, + -4.342829937403167, + -6.4063092789947405, + -2.902588959696402, + 0.20334371578218224, + 3.0567278483654263, + 4.243152769493122, + 1.011184167469935, + -2.4517628601316233, + -1.0189451511698167, + -9.235545178285236, + -12.221455489837354, + -14.629563258329313, + -13.593114130601862, + -8.191593766976098, + -6.739729807945253, + -8.215031270293878, + -4.1448912889304665 + ], + "cpisa": [ + 1.8466744253890397, + 0.9184401023186979, + 1.4053229560017257, + 2.5086074333918873, + 3.4601350482726616, + 3.30914289119778, + 4.09062994456184, + 4.115156634974596, + 4.450158639857307, + 4.278839204813892, + 4.550220306088647, + 3.4013145886482903, + 1.9126380692205203, + 1.0164898380563727, + 0.589389142292589, + -0.36285709490437057, + -1.516982915249855, + -1.8492475415254148, + -1.0218409533360955, + -1.135233581620355, + -0.6609727663703779, + -0.6899209298194933, + -0.10102570880178519, + 0.23593379221750865, + 0.7274568902028022, + 0.5506831971528072, + 2.204700812869021, + 1.889735449444288, + 1.7463414291185018, + 1.8415899587554918, + 1.7408218390917796, + 0.2503986932595126, + -1.7003308217855988, + -5.208441623921203, + -7.083305270584674, + -9.261238226981561, + -11.08406413486307, + -11.460325396293285, + -11.737758613436768, + -9.50301474701621, + -7.664091751212311, + -3.1801035562850757, + -2.0214523884445725, + 0.8347680087421736, + 0.07025443681385468, + 1.3249063768465135, + 0.07886049392595851, + -0.737723420142288, + -0.3981256076990576 + ], + "cpi_energy": [ + 14.333163373808134, + 11.068138189091655, + 9.669035067124469, + 10.963767460577515, + 17.133824462279335, + 21.643744837324107, + 20.381871093422433, + 20.0257708810891, + 24.125061046280166, + 26.49402739103209, + 22.892341307462516, + 16.353660017204106, + 5.258400172951951, + 7.144378533201575, + 3.410382526884746, + -1.6849183936335521, + -8.909544419580357, + -3.9509277073527755, + -5.070657938241311, + -5.450786744229276, + -4.427880937427176, + 0.16949320179105598, + -6.263223017437781, + -2.7516006871718446, + 0.4109496663924119, + 4.87167106521656, + 16.13793053872223, + 14.650284295290817, + 10.574446145951129, + 16.535653283591046, + 8.655707850284216, + 2.0827366223259105, + -10.567644083427012, + -27.49286825864897, + -45.15016336233032, + -51.20450691999133, + -53.76994630574984, + -41.84589188983011, + -35.87671738812389, + -16.774912705809015, + -9.925699514287203, + 27.37368159400114, + 29.274516366651824, + 44.04117030147722, + 31.418347712850164, + 24.069057147186754, + 11.230474930002856, + 9.08998745688666, + 7.78332849451408 + ], + "uk_gdp": [ + -2.1067919504835118, + -2.9108654633255355, + -2.2473393499008125, + -3.714520226033301, + -4.278249947658651, + -3.1627057082748706, + -2.715338947627515, + -2.1329384816122, + -1.6633802798928627, + -0.9674860461554999, + -0.5943773780099946, + 0.234903320839976, + 0.8286014686186718, + -0.18234038261039132, + -0.230556986474312, + 0.03683836001164309, + 0.06941856074672614, + 0.02050536156934868, + -0.31413315624445204, + -0.16453427532565001, + 0.7956949586302926, + 1.5405790027609783, + 1.9440180729125132, + 1.8544818141226642, + 1.5225080589914342, + 4.111893368977235, + 26.27709217467418, + 10.914766998927234, + 10.618282880728657, + 11.394575289305067, + 5.309984971026324, + 3.790815488750013, + -1.441579837474137, + -33.3636479272343, + -10.803092218325673, + -8.008127868864449, + -9.947355554460728, + -3.161431045902418, + -1.3848882728616445, + 0.06411695972224152, + 1.0782807333077926, + -0.41468490914689937, + -0.7570363267391258, + -0.8133676022284817, + -1.0009937339705175, + -1.405751239770325, + -2.2311529700627943, + -2.8324095889904584, + -1.8220362791344087 + ] + }, + "random_walk_errors_by_origin": { + "world_gdp": [ + -2.113642000000027, + -2.5332709999999565, + -2.9834640000000263, + -3.8173400000000015, + -4.109582000000046, + -4.348595999999986, + -4.332570999999973, + -4.351122999999973, + -4.412255000000016, + -4.4875299999999925, + -4.064005000000009, + -4.1661079999999515, + -4.044369000000017, + -4.269664000000034, + -4.478116, + -4.823327000000006, + -5.120237999999972, + -5.1404340000000275, + -5.131619000000001, + -4.661087000000009, + -4.380923999999993, + -4.401474000000007, + -4.105584000000022, + -3.670224000000019, + -3.359380999999985, + -0.39263500000004115, + 9.567363999999998, + 1.0701559999999972, + 1.1385029999999574, + 0.6237940000000322, + -0.8584260000000086, + -2.28686399999998, + -5.581058999999982, + -15.668542000000002, + -7.399136999999996, + -7.306896999999992, + -6.4908530000000155, + -4.7285889999999995, + -3.6557200000000307, + -3.0394959999999855, + -2.8056270000000154, + -2.34922499999999, + -2.124721999999963, + -2.450624000000005, + -2.5614869999999996, + -2.5342299999999796, + -2.425775000000044, + -2.6695759999999495, + -2.5532079999999837 + ], + "world_cpi": [ + -2.7771920000000136, + -1.9220149999999876, + -2.5622510000000034, + -1.6524450000000002, + -1.5554030000000125, + -0.4263419999999769, + -1.5106930000000034, + -1.0062409999999886, + -0.9606850000000122, + 0.2560750000000098, + -0.9738070000000221, + -1.0075029999999856, + -2.1075210000000197, + -1.1513439999999946, + -2.070157999999992, + -2.1625779999999963, + -3.223605999999961, + -2.3411479999999756, + -3.3760580000000004, + -3.2619909999999663, + -3.3313270000000443, + -2.241821000000016, + -3.4105010000000107, + -2.9825720000000047, + -3.3012219999999957, + -2.047435000000007, + -1.725451000000021, + -1.4802609999999845, + -1.9248029999999972, + -1.5318050000000198, + -2.766554000000042, + -2.984046000000035, + -4.8024070000000165, + -6.7329879999999775, + -9.428725999999983, + -10.754211999999995, + -11.642909999999972, + -10.811666000000002, + -11.237230000000011, + -10.159132999999997, + -8.441303000000005, + -6.149900000000002, + -5.769254000000046, + -4.337990999999988, + -4.1431460000000015, + -3.4593719999999735, + -3.703419999999994, + -3.8831160000000295, + -3.794172000000003 + ], + "oil_price": [ + 14.636653000000024, + 9.608177999999953, + 10.252324999999985, + 14.240448000000015, + 42.94307700000002, + 64.03810699999997, + 56.712154999999996, + 73.416628, + 81.35002000000003, + 98.155529, + 62.82851899999997, + 30.718207000000007, + -11.776606999999956, + -5.5263349999999605, + -16.75517400000001, + -28.181077000000016, + -59.129291999999964, + -33.76011, + -38.66274500000003, + -30.209230000000048, + -13.994123000000002, + -16.550111000000015, + -25.127075999999988, + -4.851117000000045, + 2.256212000000005, + 35.25347399999998, + 79.31673700000005, + 47.559447999999975, + 37.180222000000015, + 20.199138000000005, + 3.8631370000000516, + -5.7376259999999775, + -34.311158999999975, + -92.134976, + -87.53914399999996, + -76.18273399999998, + -38.92536100000001, + -16.525368000000014, + -0.4577489999999784, + 0.16142300000001342, + 20.872320000000002, + 42.03685999999999, + 29.02483799999999, + 27.901331000000027, + 21.296693000000005, + 8.935579999999959, + 35.343367, + 33.30654099999998, + 35.88880999999998 + ], + "bank_rate": [ + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.1577, + 0.25, + 0.25, + 0.25, + 0.25, + 0.09129999999999999, + 0.0, + -0.1577, + -0.4102, + -0.5, + -0.5, + -0.5, + -0.3413, + -0.25, + -0.11170000000000002, + 0.5602, + 0.65, + 0.65, + 0.65, + 0.65, + 0.65, + 0.4883, + -0.35629999999999995, + -0.8583000000000001, + -1.5171999999999999, + -2.7056, + -3.7555, + -4.358300000000001, + -5.0367999999999995, + -4.7937, + -4.2917, + -3.6328, + -2.2828999999999997, + -1.0, + -0.14089999999999936, + 0.8117999999999999, + 1.1462000000000003, + 1.2812000000000001 + ], + "eri": [ + -2.8862609999999904, + -2.8543240000000196, + -3.2944120000000225, + -5.100004999999953, + -8.30665799999997, + -10.440151999999955, + -11.542214000000001, + -10.544536999999991, + -7.400035000000003, + -0.06442299999997658, + 2.882548999999983, + 10.213346999999999, + 15.49171899999999, + 16.842167000000018, + 17.49514099999999, + 18.52631100000002, + 11.259499000000005, + 7.892493999999999, + -0.3579610000000457, + -1.6216229999999996, + -0.960975000000019, + -1.0214540000000056, + -2.34783299999998, + 2.5147029999999972, + -0.4919970000000262, + -0.174966999999981, + 0.5180279999999584, + 0.42464100000000826, + 1.0437819999999647, + -2.6201639999999884, + -7.652797000000021, + -2.9413490000000024, + -2.980985999999973, + -6.197496000000001, + -3.4599919999999997, + -0.2935789999999656, + 2.986655999999982, + 4.518216999999993, + 1.634232000000054, + -0.7177920000000313, + 1.4020120000000134, + -2.9435029999999642, + -5.967910000000018, + -7.686398999999994, + -7.900171999999998, + -4.396410000000003, + -3.8830090000000155, + -4.588118000000009, + -1.8809370000000172 + ], + "cpisa": [ + -3.9423029999999812, + -4.397604999999999, + -3.8141780000000267, + -2.944000000000017, + -2.1113039999999614, + -1.8542269999999803, + -1.0766179999999963, + -0.9083610000000135, + -0.45187600000002703, + -0.44190699999995786, + 0.032593000000019856, + -0.7025040000000331, + -1.540633000000014, + -2.6222799999999893, + -2.652483000000018, + -3.3730129999999576, + -4.182787000000019, + -4.966005999999993, + -4.350445999999977, + -4.660020000000031, + -4.273795000000007, + -4.076197999999977, + -3.5790040000000545, + -3.516619999999989, + -2.990506000000039, + -3.3240049999999997, + -1.7806549999999675, + -1.8924200000000155, + -1.7443329999999833, + -1.9684729999999604, + -1.9542089999999916, + -3.2161629999999946, + -4.876333999999986, + -7.3044590000000085, + -10.096643000000029, + -12.170217000000036, + -14.445149000000015, + -14.990647000000024, + -15.481713999999954, + -13.89387400000004, + -12.503922999999986, + -9.721869999999967, + -8.034196000000009, + -5.7157419999999775, + -5.256209000000013, + -4.379028000000005, + -4.963870999999983, + -5.375608999999997, + -5.089790999999991 + ], + "cpi_energy": [ + -2.2712060000000065, + -3.7753260000000637, + -4.1187609999999495, + -2.320235000000025, + 3.309080999999992, + 8.66075699999999, + 7.50926800000002, + 8.339929999999981, + 12.714856000000054, + 15.348154000000022, + 12.579175000000077, + 8.12598300000002, + 0.1305169999999407, + -0.2632140000000618, + -1.7915179999999964, + -5.504602000000091, + -10.834148000000027, + -9.17177700000002, + -10.328546999999958, + -11.545807999999965, + -10.669011999999952, + -5.083257000000003, + -11.583664999999996, + -9.187021000000072, + -5.339064000000008, + -1.9142719999999827, + 9.06958899999995, + 8.24541499999998, + 5.687238999999977, + 9.566793000000075, + 2.4359400000000733, + -3.016224999999963, + -13.057664000000045, + -24.17670499999997, + -48.77328299999999, + -53.78481399999998, + -58.24831500000005, + -47.43270600000005, + -41.71135200000003, + -24.981253000000038, + -19.01571899999999, + 7.6868709999999965, + 14.560115999999994, + 28.218193000000042, + 22.312981000000036, + 17.142021999999997, + 9.351392000000033, + 8.759849000000031, + 7.19661700000006 + ], + "uk_gdp": [ + -3.1817469999998593, + -4.032660999999962, + -3.9381699999999, + -4.893385999999964, + -5.2861709999999675, + -4.926453000000038, + -4.618783000000121, + -4.348500000000058, + -4.148087000000032, + -3.7137780000000475, + -3.635911999999962, + -3.4186899999999696, + -3.732580999999982, + -4.226520999999821, + -4.689033999999992, + -4.766039000000092, + -5.011637999999948, + -4.357248999999911, + -4.13406400000008, + -3.8335409999999683, + -3.0137580000000526, + -2.666825000000017, + -2.2053589999998167, + -2.006738000000041, + -1.934221000000207, + 1.0663900000001831, + 23.580077999999958, + 8.039567999999917, + 7.183426999999938, + 8.478432999999995, + 2.278246000000081, + 0.6116309999999885, + -3.539899000000105, + -26.74527400000011, + -11.63147200000003, + -10.373824999999897, + -11.715734000000111, + -5.0228870000000825, + -3.3916499999997995, + -1.7835210000000643, + -0.45331199999986893, + -0.6223889999998846, + -1.1405839999999898, + -1.059526999999889, + -1.435228000000052, + -1.9656420000001162, + -2.361267999999882, + -2.7581700000000637, + -2.0834990000000744 + ] } }, { "horizon": 8, "variables_beating_random_walk": 3, + "n_origins": 49, "relative_rmse_by_variable": { "world_gdp": 0.7107677610271683, "world_cpi": 0.6741103874429449, @@ -275,13 +6214,855 @@ "cpisa": 7.098202678865948, "cpi_energy": 20.562150664140567, "uk_gdp": 7.071764877500815 + }, + "dm_stat_by_variable": { + "world_gdp": -1.948362528943324, + "world_cpi": -1.796711530195696, + "oil_price": 0.5523746876498333, + "bank_rate": 0.7723577151656372, + "eri": 2.2532863287530374, + "cpisa": -1.628723045080072, + "cpi_energy": 1.142706003389539, + "uk_gdp": 0.4270760784395219 + }, + "dm_pvalue_by_variable": { + "world_gdp": 0.05723097285309008, + "world_cpi": 0.07867530812689917, + "oil_price": 0.5832548007958998, + "bank_rate": 0.44368901719107834, + "eri": 0.0288468373693847, + "cpisa": 0.10991827956370603, + "cpi_energy": 0.25882849355442317, + "uk_gdp": 0.6712335798029894 + }, + "bvar_errors_by_origin": { + "world_gdp": [ + 0.7429406240945582, + 0.09640335172366576, + -0.532608488143353, + -1.6315279878623414, + -2.528090639035611, + -1.7881052836216327, + -1.6491010062497367, + -1.4657929058922718, + -1.540079575406537, + -1.2066260946547231, + -0.8239797486981502, + -0.6481478223767567, + 0.44225655873691494, + -0.0644790385106262, + -0.03046857139804615, + -0.2263321868409207, + 0.33594825548533436, + -0.6499808192431829, + -0.7778650978694372, + -0.5341027043151598, + -0.4052354642459477, + 0.059682917484110476, + 0.41472061220974865, + 1.1336548190774351, + 3.470456605880713, + 13.445002026473617, + 4.4437800352625345, + 4.4458988858665975, + 4.568595426593447, + 2.8480471268282486, + 1.9175585565070605, + 1.058728746175177, + -2.782154732095364, + -17.110466763252646, + -4.509876223967808, + -3.281936410810374, + -2.6517055907853546, + -1.499737134782663, + -0.26225796206455243, + 0.2726318621502628, + -0.027588561136894896, + -0.6201354798373018, + -0.35040203538301284, + -0.5828548969716962, + -0.6811266673037153, + -0.3902769146316132, + -0.818583923081178, + -0.8574859096747787, + -0.6506058230686449 + ], + "world_cpi": [ + 1.512606377418308, + 1.782937473680363, + 1.8453865666431852, + 2.5025620699332762, + 3.137737476036989, + 2.553910291958914, + 2.6499496240295457, + 2.937423046785341, + 3.3259563846067977, + 3.0419630327833147, + 2.5830201237549772, + 1.9100726158345651, + 0.6588924611651805, + 1.4213907940672357, + 0.9317600173697542, + 0.29174740323333026, + -0.8302283447561649, + -0.396704848842262, + -0.7928887592671003, + -0.5294587364725203, + -0.07872445292349539, + -0.5251130961124204, + -0.5663060930676238, + -0.46218374786002414, + -0.2827928860583029, + 0.9540849945196896, + 1.3432743047397935, + 1.3615105120123872, + 0.17698611404608755, + 0.18447663649573087, + -0.4638246608271288, + -1.7242195172139532, + -4.432101086589057, + -7.5553662320194235, + -8.128403676998403, + -9.858284290970289, + -9.328237200032333, + -8.991359822919776, + -8.76470093326975, + -7.079947891407926, + -5.0288361426165125, + -2.319346311399727, + -1.2662287492697715, + 0.688730068196719, + -0.02499515167755817, + 0.6446206429897643, + 0.5120156758977714, + 0.11497602467522938, + 0.0981074618325124 + ], + "oil_price": [ + 50.101151800718185, + 37.818106813739576, + 44.42445481443025, + 61.29069163371429, + 96.2290026861375, + 75.2119035641557, + 101.44069841896277, + 105.50910057371237, + 117.03637528445324, + 89.09379247619717, + 73.46696936910087, + 35.83324681078017, + -0.6104638733907564, + 23.83599904315969, + -1.5193337125965058, + -27.26667088783745, + -48.595559047766244, + -29.427061450800238, + -25.89675245928305, + -3.7501430921353744, + 7.4374162093437235, + -12.88980423156022, + -6.332797525492822, + 9.093366707390885, + 30.827684352276947, + 82.6931061801161, + 63.5613767127316, + 51.45205527142451, + 20.66832752513926, + 16.50960376851333, + 5.334578186084002, + -7.800166522937218, + -44.580090177890156, + -101.70062850963046, + -63.900054009139524, + -49.978178428435456, + -16.38354695178299, + -0.12368470611511384, + -2.840227754958619, + 4.662346476017603, + 23.614746085979164, + 31.71208323686392, + 27.400480440294473, + 8.79162390528262, + -8.178616696142512, + -3.140634775227113, + 8.136677606038006, + 17.316769829576856, + -5.867063645438975 + ], + "bank_rate": [ + -0.4224888430978013, + -0.3715686515555279, + -0.27892972208780126, + -0.4798483968999516, + -0.5801465692377635, + -0.2224563808656594, + -0.17565254758138682, + -0.08539533942134742, + -0.04621385564174679, + 0.031761746977673866, + 0.2045259517538381, + 0.39239806456464477, + 0.7294833058310208, + 0.7223619393964195, + 0.7436610604112872, + 0.6523901484844181, + 0.5365515874534732, + 0.484369959117799, + -0.2142490720859785, + -0.3569399438491499, + -0.26821344241749717, + -0.1549814327067519, + -0.25786008982872444, + -0.10165719419474073, + -0.08007341229405374, + 0.3400773684350612, + 0.31210886216661704, + 0.44709643799244225, + 0.6461434337407025, + 0.5626284169595731, + 0.47229959730799453, + 0.5844275661665209, + -0.43735059815413685, + -1.442002813398937, + -1.1305992137783885, + -2.365212623362988, + -3.4922152364168566, + -4.2096827828277235, + -5.114420658179294, + -5.314048413068462, + -5.035213128152866, + -4.768548313724865, + -3.970533737336954, + -2.1623990203065144, + -0.9352662813902888, + 0.14003867344917698, + 1.0109562123670033, + 0.8561607591277403, + 1.180794881120943 + ], + "eri": [ + -9.54458329713168, + -6.392799926407463, + -5.644601565016444, + -6.076334359186831, + -14.65644060280465, + -14.89519284968327, + -15.741901349859347, + -10.477532879247576, + -1.1378371049408997, + 2.585977680576832, + 12.899334368283746, + 16.33427164547288, + 21.368827672715497, + 20.473206673278582, + 26.20896822651531, + 24.36770729169075, + 15.250800858718605, + 10.642142609397354, + 0.42373254828009976, + -3.258863135607669, + -3.2251308158046754, + -0.7192871170530566, + 0.06441315001870862, + -3.3131470184017076, + -1.2986046656466783, + 0.4070770246023585, + -2.2470629611607364, + -2.3029438572327763, + -2.7687396345890534, + -6.437516816172433, + -10.140677879731811, + -3.571598340972969, + -5.227163985573895, + -3.551260352378222, + -0.3958259129386761, + 0.24903858665004464, + 2.876811827833876, + 1.3052880963163034, + -1.2490307271575602, + -1.3742062295017945, + -2.9569001458020807, + -10.26986405840347, + -14.481864317455745, + -15.710848729415659, + -13.65069218375504, + -10.359244097108785, + -6.628455543628718, + -7.649826099523125, + -5.215704486857987 + ], + "cpisa": [ + 2.1576791664454618, + 1.7148225427330885, + 1.8492056765853704, + 3.2826919071894167, + 4.531549589957081, + 4.2083944360992405, + 4.45085126453796, + 4.7586415954030485, + 5.187832471709214, + 5.112920265723915, + 4.453894545478761, + 3.4238129259393872, + 1.50417151392179, + 1.1222827630992924, + 0.26354564139865033, + -0.699460300007388, + -1.748371505173452, + -1.5452876082836156, + -1.4440799354081264, + -1.1902999557568137, + -0.37403392436237937, + -0.5125574446032601, + -0.3257512035533523, + 0.6567724401175496, + 0.7851799684642629, + 1.746007934542945, + 2.100197207501367, + 2.351906274927103, + 1.7313398166782576, + 1.660518961254411, + 0.8950165415153606, + -1.3791816657436584, + -3.005430250218126, + -8.293934611597194, + -8.794528696758334, + -11.641178525257203, + -11.870359843927247, + -12.83929988614716, + -11.774642775794575, + -9.326589550429617, + -7.726357682341302, + -2.9212541774819556, + -1.7897839755565883, + 0.8067800470752218, + -0.20198079279435888, + 0.9468634111883034, + -0.006858139199550806, + -0.4421531923945281, + -0.45063394376569477 + ], + "cpi_energy": [ + 15.603626472187784, + 13.724849121887928, + 11.947282857829578, + 16.03441011865982, + 25.14835192983969, + 21.73721535243169, + 23.80539397446171, + 24.907803235816004, + 28.859516538858202, + 25.552822630782543, + 23.006095994138036, + 15.578778913169913, + 4.016849393647931, + 8.246953090785155, + 3.763566421648534, + -3.2478214905862615, + -9.312926875340736, + -5.775419448071943, + -7.610736131539397, + -5.958036943202615, + 2.062408647917664, + -6.071129233553961, + -5.348011885784331, + 1.0986472051589544, + 2.1460466876892497, + 13.51968275150466, + 14.9835997755672, + 18.689175132902847, + 8.223881666456919, + 10.50344629757501, + 7.097475239580035, + -6.26396850881838, + -13.312012050545377, + -54.06101130166144, + -46.57177038822044, + -58.40597260568677, + -49.37546597263224, + -37.872238271276956, + -27.542407768994167, + -13.239359277400354, + -8.917844002369861, + 34.09935893560589, + 36.948669570629704, + 43.70497942780253, + 30.75785554587094, + 24.79500037583307, + 13.530901835930422, + 7.682922623584204, + 6.595882333707891 + ], + "uk_gdp": [ + -2.8476712240578763, + -3.760256473887466, + -2.91059772204585, + -4.233851116736332, + -4.46757161567848, + -3.4408105269087628, + -2.9175456593743547, + -2.4961135087526145, + -1.8896497004786852, + -1.4040970597075102, + -0.6894481216886561, + 0.07301018827843109, + 0.45035810056765513, + -0.5348691088802298, + -0.3073124959616962, + -0.06566098986354518, + 0.7017551010796979, + 0.3775550281620781, + -0.08275959867910387, + 0.20780059165235798, + 0.7922239832018931, + 1.8825104284223926, + 1.9526037465343506, + 2.346282075412546, + 4.782706524913465, + 26.72398245939644, + 10.999334226939027, + 9.975296501703497, + 12.149294548753005, + 5.0501973838863705, + 4.072568195876329, + 2.864669781273051, + -1.9932098245935777, + -34.07608332207792, + -10.622552284143467, + -7.924726988202792, + -9.785500519933748, + -2.8812091499646613, + -0.8109756747651318, + 0.7028829308667355, + 0.58309793015178, + -0.9469211548885141, + -0.8160525586206404, + -1.1341572975820782, + -1.4397762137232348, + -1.413588823224245, + -2.2503694925369473, + -2.837058356796433, + -2.3450814894063114 + ] + }, + "random_walk_errors_by_origin": { + "world_gdp": [ + -2.5639869999999974, + -3.102798000000007, + -3.7474809999999934, + -4.356952000000035, + -5.039782000000002, + -4.919016999999997, + -4.859571999999957, + -4.862599999999986, + -5.057057000000043, + -4.828021999999976, + -4.705719999999985, + -4.974568999999974, + -4.840085000000045, + -5.005116999999984, + -5.33480400000002, + -5.765039999999999, + -5.480926000000011, + -5.773333999999977, + -5.469548000000032, + -5.17664000000002, + -5.136926999999957, + -4.962272000000041, + -4.611937000000012, + -3.7200690000000236, + -1.0255349999999908, + 9.229434999999967, + 0.554602999999986, + 0.3824999999999932, + 0.06299599999999828, + -1.3647789999999986, + -2.336708999999985, + -3.247212999999988, + -6.046471999999994, + -16.411898000000008, + -7.994552999999996, + -7.566359999999975, + -6.71716200000003, + -5.134003000000007, + -3.9998449999999934, + -3.2710400000000277, + -3.0925809999999956, + -2.720137999999963, + -2.7100869999999873, + -2.7877960000000144, + -2.939643999999987, + -2.769900000000007, + -2.9011199999999917, + -2.840161999999964, + -2.6949960000000033 + ], + "world_cpi": [ + -2.8032210000000077, + -2.589934000000028, + -2.4056779999999662, + -1.696183000000019, + -0.9497230000000059, + -1.5838149999999587, + -1.3840280000000007, + -0.9867140000000063, + -0.4118440000000305, + -0.8172339999999849, + -1.0512410000000045, + -1.501841000000013, + -2.3088169999999764, + -1.9434929999999895, + -2.143051000000014, + -2.6747649999999794, + -3.4144569999999703, + -3.453491999999983, + -3.756328999999994, + -3.532623000000001, + -3.0339700000000107, + -3.4833940000000325, + -3.4947589999999877, + -3.492073000000005, + -3.1597790000000145, + -2.1057220000000143, + -1.7508930000000191, + -1.6274459999999635, + -2.7733780000000365, + -2.850812000000019, + -3.493547000000035, + -4.660964000000035, + -6.791274999999985, + -9.454167999999981, + -10.901396999999974, + -12.491485000000011, + -12.130673000000002, + -11.964223000000004, + -11.836050999999998, + -10.430170999999973, + -8.871080000000006, + -7.2419250000000375, + -6.075264000000004, + -4.630909000000031, + -4.611928999999975, + -4.302240999999981, + -4.1541540000000055, + -4.223949000000005, + -4.227142000000015 + ], + "oil_price": [ + 18.71042399999999, + 9.621797999999956, + 16.811281000000008, + 38.20077100000003, + 72.05233399999997, + 51.57439999999997, + 78.87656300000003, + 85.423791, + 98.169149, + 69.387475, + 54.67853000000002, + 17.33265, + -17.99004199999996, + 5.409234000000026, + -16.173914000000025, + -42.31016299999999, + -62.528164000000004, + -46.81273399999998, + -43.59478700000005, + -20.207558000000006, + -5.614542000000029, + -24.545816000000002, + -18.980203000000017, + -1.1426600000000349, + 22.200850000000003, + 74.38469500000002, + 57.56112000000002, + 45.55980299999999, + 12.203433000000018, + 10.010010000000023, + -2.0291689999999676, + -14.366520999999977, + -53.003754999999956, + -109.294761, + -78.18237899999997, + -63.902150000000006, + -26.714495999999997, + -6.350054999999998, + -8.467471999999987, + 2.1797240000000215, + 24.87707499999999, + 38.381602999999984, + 40.181915000000004, + 33.50755800000002, + 19.110892999999976, + 27.333643999999993, + 35.32484199999999, + 39.89356499999997, + 17.106085000000007 + ], + "bank_rate": [ + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.1577, + 0.25, + 0.25, + 0.25, + 0.25, + 0.09129999999999999, + 0.0, + 0.0, + -0.3179, + -0.5, + -0.5, + -0.5, + -0.5, + -0.3413, + -0.11170000000000002, + 0.4, + 0.5602, + 0.65, + 0.65, + 0.65, + 0.65, + 0.6266, + 0.15540000000000004, + -0.8583000000000001, + -1.5171999999999999, + -2.7056, + -3.7555, + -4.358300000000001, + -5.0602, + -5.1266, + -4.7937, + -4.2917, + -3.4713, + -2.0499, + -0.7436999999999996, + 0.10990000000000055, + 1.0564, + 1.2812000000000001, + 1.5 + ], + "eri": [ + -5.266332000000034, + -4.402083000000005, + -4.558584999999994, + -4.275729999999953, + -10.682875999999965, + -12.425925000000007, + -13.357031999999947, + -9.780106000000046, + -1.6121819999999616, + 1.618376000000012, + 11.037621999999999, + 13.115500999999995, + 14.856393999999966, + 15.680323000000044, + 19.290741999999966, + 17.047352000000046, + 9.575292999999988, + 7.79711199999997, + 1.2805309999999963, + -1.596300000000042, + -2.1832979999999793, + -0.5522320000000036, + 1.0357440000000224, + -2.1762030000000436, + -0.27034900000001016, + 2.1565200000000004, + 0.44996399999996584, + -0.17854099999999562, + -2.1509419999999864, + -4.2692200000000184, + -7.632255000000043, + -2.759337999999957, + -3.8660090000000196, + -3.5280559999999923, + -0.8967609999999695, + -0.20806799999996883, + 2.8691609999999628, + 1.6547740000000317, + -0.5357809999999859, + 0.5169889999999668, + -0.27406299999995554, + -3.4046789999999874, + -7.600887999999998, + -8.017667000000017, + -7.259852999999964, + -6.053022000000055, + -3.3533370000000104, + -3.557011999999986, + -2.6406670000000076 + ], + "cpisa": [ + -4.492439999999988, + -4.390700000000038, + -4.146024000000011, + -2.971183999999994, + -1.8597319999999513, + -1.7134639999999877, + -1.4750520000000051, + -1.0020130000000336, + -0.4350019999999972, + -0.2992529999999647, + -0.7296880000000101, + -1.2890610000000038, + -2.4815169999999966, + -3.0509170000000267, + -3.4666649999999777, + -4.165912999999989, + -4.823352, + -5.112727000000007, + -5.246577000000002, + -5.21467899999999, + -4.504835000000014, + -4.393186000000014, + -4.3095200000000204, + -3.63107100000002, + -3.4707260000000133, + -2.676785999999993, + -2.447078999999974, + -1.9753729999999905, + -2.285460999999998, + -2.6847249999999576, + -3.3306140000000255, + -5.35655399999996, + -6.657240000000002, + -10.763067000000035, + -12.253170000000011, + -14.98627700000003, + -15.706899000000021, + -16.858118999999988, + -16.034265000000005, + -14.284829000000002, + -13.180477999999994, + -10.190722999999991, + -8.53180199999997, + -6.517959000000019, + -6.246499999999969, + -5.516422000000034, + -5.76656399999996, + -5.766345999999999, + -5.824988000000019 + ], + "cpi_energy": [ + -3.4531990000000405, + -3.33113000000003, + -3.870537000000013, + 0.7565829999999778, + 9.265194000000065, + 6.871407999999974, + 9.095189000000005, + 11.53286300000002, + 15.792350000000056, + 12.827399000000014, + 11.202801000000022, + 6.086630000000014, + -2.0525630000000774, + -0.20559700000001158, + -2.3116690000000517, + -7.756654000000026, + -11.692532000000028, + -11.704921000000013, + -13.585160999999971, + -12.85209199999997, + -5.025639999999953, + -12.103816000000052, + -11.439073000000008, + -6.1974480000000085, + -4.447415999999976, + 5.812974999999938, + 6.939130999999975, + 11.330610999999976, + 2.5462340000000268, + 2.580532000000062, + -0.02665199999989909, + -12.166016000000013, + -16.44945800000005, + -50.90374099999997, + -50.69961799999999, + -61.38932, + -54.418967000000066, + -44.173944000000006, + -34.13104400000009, + -22.407512999999994, + -19.040165000000002, + 12.633780999999999, + 20.613687000000027, + 26.142329000000018, + 20.400784000000044, + 16.931699999999978, + 11.333589000000075, + 7.1721710000000485, + 5.834024999999997 + ], + "uk_gdp": [ + -3.9796309999999266, + -4.969110000000001, + -4.748906999999917, + -5.5511189999999715, + -5.589365999999927, + -5.381964000000153, + -5.005773999999974, + -4.9459710000001, + -4.650227000000086, + -4.446648999999979, + -4.076422999999977, + -4.035775999999942, + -4.682031999999936, + -5.076024999999845, + -5.363510000000133, + -5.513778000000002, + -5.0901199999998425, + -4.574575000000095, + -4.45062699999994, + -3.963209000000006, + -3.5163290000000416, + -2.8798349999999573, + -2.7544769999999517, + -2.0127030000001014, + 0.8490639999999985, + 23.263515000000098, + 7.90989999999988, + 6.680855999999949, + 8.265423000000055, + 1.729127999999946, + 0.6056659999999283, + -0.7566139999998995, + -4.548149000000194, + -27.30165000000011, + -11.732536999999866, + -10.633737999999994, + -11.772192000000132, + -5.064229999999952, + -3.1517659999999523, + -1.461561999999958, + -1.1787649999998848, + -1.2416489999998248, + -1.319439999999986, + -1.4916860000000725, + -2.006984999999986, + -2.1213840000000346, + -2.4362109999999575, + -2.8089520000000903, + -2.710886999999957 + ] } } ], "limitations": [ "Errors use the transformed model units supplied by the caller.", "This evaluates reduced-form forecasts, not structural identification.", - "No-change is a minimum benchmark, not an official forecast comparison." + "No-change is a minimum benchmark, not an official forecast comparison.", + "Diebold-Mariano p-values are per (variable, horizon) and are not adjusted for testing the whole grid.", + "Estimation uses final (revised) data, so this is pseudo- not real-time out-of-sample." ], "variables": [ "world_gdp", diff --git a/validation/index.html b/validation/index.html index d102bb9..a392e4c 100644 --- a/validation/index.html +++ b/validation/index.html @@ -156,7 +156,7 @@

Software fidelity and economic validity are separate.

Evidence dimensionobr-macroboe-svarfrb-us Implementation fidelityModerate — incomplete channelsStrong — restrictions and identities gatedStrong — four gated scenarios at the reference-solver noise floor - Predictive validationWeak — raw GDP 5.75%, consumption 9.56% MAPEModerate — CPI beats no change; GDP does not in rolling testsNot assessed — LONGBASE is not a Fed forecast + Predictive validationWeak — raw GDP 5.75%, consumption 9.56% MAPEModerate — CPI significantly beats no change at short horizons; GDP is statistically indistinguishable from itNot assessed — LONGBASE is not a Fed forecast Identification robustnessNot applicableModerate — proxy data and specification matterNot applicable Policy-counterfactual validityWeak — one independent tax benchmark, constrained channelsNot applicable — reform scoring refusedModerate — published ranges, VAR expectations only Uncertainty calibrationWeak — sensitivity envelopes pendingModerate — posterior bands, limited coverage historyWeak — bootstrap engine exists, public runs remain deterministic @@ -900,7 +900,7 @@

boe-svar against a random walk, computed from our own runs

boe-svar RMSE relative to a random walk, by horizon - Line chart of RMSE ratios versus a random-walk benchmark at horizons one to eight quarters. UK CPI stays between 0.62 and 0.68 at all horizons, well below the 1.0 parity line. UK real GDP sits between 1.06 and 1.09 at all horizons, slightly above parity. Expanding-window evaluation with 49 origins from 2012Q1 to 2024Q1. + Line chart of RMSE ratios versus a random-walk benchmark at horizons one to eight quarters. UK CPI stays between 0.62 and 0.68 at all horizons, well below the 1.0 parity line, and the difference is statistically significant at short horizons (Diebold-Mariano p below 0.005 at one quarter). UK real GDP sits between 1.06 and 1.09, slightly above parity, but that gap is not statistically significant at any horizon (p from 0.38 to 0.67) — the model is indistinguishable from the benchmark for GDP rather than beaten by it. Expanding-window evaluation with 49 origins from 2012Q1 to 2024Q1. RMSE ÷ random-walk RMSE · horizons 1–8 quarters · below 1.0 beats naive 1.2 From 7371b7477eca6eff0cdb1bfee4c50aa3f186d911 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Vahid Ahmadi Date: Fri, 24 Jul 2026 16:32:03 +0100 Subject: [PATCH 3/3] Remove the ambient dot field style.css documented at length that field.js was "now deleted along with its markup" and replaced by a static lattice, because animated ornament behind continuous technical prose is a reading hazard. The deletion was never carried out in the HTML: the canvas was still loaded on all 12 pages and still drifting behind the body copy, and the stylesheet's own comments contradicted the rendered page. Removes the script and canvas from all 12 pages, deletes field.js, and drops the now-dead #field rules including the dark-mode override. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) --- connect/index.html | 2 - contact/index.html | 3 +- docs/index.html | 2 - field.js | 120 ------------------------------- frb-us/index.html | 2 - index.html | 2 - models/index.html | 3 +- obr/index.html | 2 - olg/index.html | 2 - papers/index.html | 2 - pe/index.html | 2 - reports/us-hank-open-source.html | 90 +++++++++++++++++++++++ style.css | 12 ---- svar/index.html | 2 - validation/index.html | 2 - 15 files changed, 92 insertions(+), 156 deletions(-) delete mode 100644 field.js create mode 100644 reports/us-hank-open-source.html diff --git a/connect/index.html b/connect/index.html index f214d5b..bb3e259 100644 --- a/connect/index.html +++ b/connect/index.html @@ -238,7 +238,6 @@ -
@@ -434,6 +433,5 @@

Use a model package directly.

}); })(); - diff --git a/contact/index.html b/contact/index.html index 001330c..3f11fd0 100644 --- a/contact/index.html +++ b/contact/index.html @@ -15,7 +15,6 @@ -
PolicyEngine Macro - + diff --git a/docs/index.html b/docs/index.html index 7df4a13..af13f0f 100644 --- a/docs/index.html +++ b/docs/index.html @@ -39,7 +39,6 @@ -
@@ -147,7 +146,6 @@

Compare two models

- - diff --git a/index.html b/index.html index 6f6c1d4..c62a310 100644 --- a/index.html +++ b/index.html @@ -24,7 +24,6 @@ -
@@ -228,6 +227,5 @@

Add the models to Claude or ChatGPT—or use them in your own code.

- diff --git a/models/index.html b/models/index.html index ff33b42..a1ae397 100644 --- a/models/index.html +++ b/models/index.html @@ -15,7 +15,6 @@ -
PolicyEngine Macro - + diff --git a/obr/index.html b/obr/index.html index 9eb15f2..bf1fa3a 100644 --- a/obr/index.html +++ b/obr/index.html @@ -28,7 +28,6 @@ -
@@ -426,6 +425,5 @@

What is broken, and what is merely absent.

}); }); - diff --git a/olg/index.html b/olg/index.html index 6a901dd..bbdfdff 100644 --- a/olg/index.html +++ b/olg/index.html @@ -28,7 +28,6 @@ -
@@ -414,6 +413,5 @@

Experimental-grade wiring, stated plainly.

}); }); - diff --git a/papers/index.html b/papers/index.html index b9980fb..a9ccf08 100644 --- a/papers/index.html +++ b/papers/index.html @@ -27,7 +27,6 @@ -
@@ -84,6 +83,5 @@

- diff --git a/pe/index.html b/pe/index.html index 9b531bc..b294a48 100644 --- a/pe/index.html +++ b/pe/index.html @@ -28,7 +28,6 @@ -
@@ -369,6 +368,5 @@

Scope and vintage.

}); }); - diff --git a/reports/us-hank-open-source.html b/reports/us-hank-open-source.html new file mode 100644 index 0000000..ae4cb3e --- /dev/null +++ b/reports/us-hank-open-source.html @@ -0,0 +1,90 @@ + + + + + + Open US HANK models — code, data, reach + + + +
+
+
+
PolicyEngine Macro · feasibility note
+

Open US HANK models

+

Public code, data, citations, GitHub activity and analytical coverage. Citation counts use canonical OpenAlex records; stars use the GitHub API.

+
+
AS OF 21 JUL 2026
A4 · ONE-PAGE EDITION
+
+ +

Best complete candidate: Bayer–Born–Lütticke provides the clearest combination of a US-calibrated model, public data, estimation machinery, replication targets and an explicit GPL-3.0 licence. Sequence-Space Jacobian is the strongest Python foundation, but is not itself a fully estimated institutional US model.

+ +
+ + + + + + + + + + +
Model / resourceYearCitationsStarsCode and dataCoverage
Bayer–Born–Lütticke
Shocks, Frictions, and Inequality in US Business Cycles		2024464Both available
Julia · GPL-3.0		US business cycles; income and wealth inequality; one-/two-asset households; portfolio choice; fiscal and monetary shocks; Bayesian estimation. Aggregate quarterly data approximately 1954Q3–2019Q4.
FRBNY Estimating HANK
Central-bank estimation and forecast evaluation		2023105Code + BBL data
Julia · licence not explicit		Recursive Bayesian estimation and pseudo-out-of-sample forecasts; output, consumption, investment, wages, hours, inflation, policy/shadow rates and inequality; comparison with Smets–Wouters.
Kaplan–Moll–Violante
Monetary Policy According to HANK		20181,359N/ABoth available
Fortran · ICPSR; licence unclear		US monetary transmission; liquid and illiquid assets; hand-to-mouth households; earnings risk; wealth and MPC distributions; aggregate consumption responses. Scientific replication rather than forecasting.
Sequence-Space Jacobian
One- and two-asset HANK examples		2021245351Python framework + example inputs
MIT; no full US dataset		Steady states, Jacobians, likelihoods, impulse responses and perfect-foresight transitions. Broad modelling framework, not a specific official US empirical model.
Fed Board HANK Comes of Age
Monetary policy with heterogeneous overlapping generations		2024/250*N/ADownloadable materials
No maintained official GitHub repo; licence unclear		US life cycle: age, labour supply, wealth, retirement, MPCs, monetary transmission, asset repricing, consumption and welfare by age.
+
+ +

Source links

+
    +
  1. 1ABBL model code · data · paper · citations
    2. +
  2. 1BFRBNY code · report · citations
    3. +
  3. 2Kaplan–Moll–Violante code/data · paper · citations
    4. +
  4. 3Sequence-Jacobian code · one-asset · two-asset · citations
    5. +
  5. 4HANK Comes of Age paper/materials · DOI · citations
    6. +
+ +
* OpenAlex reports zero citations on the revised DOI record; citations to earlier versions may be split or delayed.“N/A” means no official GitHub repository—not zero popularity.
+
+ + diff --git a/style.css b/style.css index 744ae9e..5574d4a 100644 --- a/style.css +++ b/style.css @@ -1458,18 +1458,6 @@ h2 { readable because text no longer fades in (the reveal animation that used to hold copy at opacity:0 is retired). Motion stops under prefers-reduced-motion, handled in field.js. */ -#field { - position: fixed; - inset: 0; - z-index: -2; - width: 100%; - height: 100%; - opacity: 0.55; - pointer-events: none; - -webkit-mask-image: linear-gradient(to bottom, #000 0, #000 42vh, transparent 88vh); - mask-image: linear-gradient(to bottom, #000 0, #000 42vh, transparent 88vh); -} -@media (prefers-color-scheme: dark) { #field { opacity: 0.7; } } /* The verdict band — "how far to trust it" on every model page, and the validation summary. This is the suite's distinguishing claim (each model diff --git a/svar/index.html b/svar/index.html index 15bff9d..b7c984a 100644 --- a/svar/index.html +++ b/svar/index.html @@ -28,7 +28,6 @@ -
@@ -458,6 +457,5 @@

The paper, the code, the method.

}); }); - diff --git a/validation/index.html b/validation/index.html index a392e4c..9f3b2cc 100644 --- a/validation/index.html +++ b/validation/index.html @@ -42,7 +42,6 @@ -
@@ -1015,7 +1014,6 @@

Our OBR emulator: replication accuracy, not forecast accuracy

-