add HDPE water pipeline and water booster pump#277
Conversation
|
Hi @euronion :) |
|
Yes, I'll review. Next time feel free to ping me with the PR as soon as you feel like it is ready for review. :) |
euronion
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Thanks for the contribution, see the comments below and let me know if you have any question!
| HDPE water pipeline,investment,2023,1588,EUR/(m^3-H2O/h)/km,2023,"HYPAT_WP_Water-Supply-for-Electrolysis-Plants, https://hypat.de/hypat-wAssets/docs/new/publikationen/HYPAT_WP_Water-Supply-for-Electrolysis-Plants.pdf -> Based on pipe diamter 171.65mm and 16 Bars with flow 34.71 kg/s. Considered mass flow rate for 1000 MW Electrolyzer",High-density polyethylene (HDPE) water pipeline cost | ||
| HDPE water pipeline,FOM,2023,5,%/year,2023,"HYPAT_WP_Water-Supply-for-Electrolysis-Plants, https://hypat.de/hypat-wAssets/docs/new/publikationen/HYPAT_WP_Water-Supply-for-Electrolysis-Plants.pdf", | ||
| HDPE water pipeline,lifetime,2023,50,years,2023,"HYPAT_WP_Water-Supply-for-Electrolysis-Plants, https://hypat.de/hypat-wAssets/docs/new/publikationen/HYPAT_WP_Water-Supply-for-Electrolysis-Plants.pdf", |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
-
Please rename it to "water pipeline HDPE", i.e. that the name reflects broader category -> diameter -> material details. So some of the info that you put in the details should also go into the name
-
Can you add the figure where you extracted the data from in the report? (Probably figure 4-7?) and the date when you accessed the publication.
-
The currency year should be 2022 instead of 2023, can you confirm/check?
-
Are there any insights about the technology year of this data, whether this is from 1981 (like the pump station data)? Else we can keep it as 2023
| HDPE water pipeline,investment,2023,1588,EUR/(m^3-H2O/h)/km,2023,"HYPAT_WP_Water-Supply-for-Electrolysis-Plants, https://hypat.de/hypat-wAssets/docs/new/publikationen/HYPAT_WP_Water-Supply-for-Electrolysis-Plants.pdf -> Based on pipe diamter 171.65mm and 16 Bars with flow 34.71 kg/s. Considered mass flow rate for 1000 MW Electrolyzer",High-density polyethylene (HDPE) water pipeline cost | ||
| HDPE water pipeline,FOM,2023,5,%/year,2023,"HYPAT_WP_Water-Supply-for-Electrolysis-Plants, https://hypat.de/hypat-wAssets/docs/new/publikationen/HYPAT_WP_Water-Supply-for-Electrolysis-Plants.pdf", | ||
| HDPE water pipeline,lifetime,2023,50,years,2023,"HYPAT_WP_Water-Supply-for-Electrolysis-Plants, https://hypat.de/hypat-wAssets/docs/new/publikationen/HYPAT_WP_Water-Supply-for-Electrolysis-Plants.pdf", | ||
| water booster pump,investment,2023,4775,EUR/kW,2023,"Calculated based on HYPAT_WP_Water-Supply-for-Electrolysis-Plants, https://hypat.de/hypat-wAssets/docs/new/publikationen/HYPAT_WP_Water-Supply-for-Electrolysis-Plants.pdf",Cost of water booster pump per horsepower |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Similar points as for the technology above:
- rename to something like "water pipeline booster pump"
- Exact location where the info is taken from the publication (I couldn't locate the origin of the data from the pub)
- It seems like the publication uses a formula with a scaling exponent != 1, so if you make an assumption on the HP of the pump, add this assumptions and ideally also the calculation to the details.
- Check technology (1981?) and currency year (2022)
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Hi @doneachh and @euronion . I was the one working on this for the PR. So the source of the costs come from the formula (17) in : https://hypat.de/hypat-wAssets/docs/new/publikationen/HYPAT_WP_Water-Supply-for-Electrolysis-Plants.pdf
And the original sourcce of the formula comes from this report: https://www.countyofmonterey.gov/home/showdocument?id=18882
Where the 15570 USD are from 1981. So I used this formula to convert this number with a constant inflation of 2%:
Pump investment in millions Eur
invest_pumping_station = pump_station_cost_kw( power_kw=power_kW, usd_to_eur=snakemake.params.costs["default_exchange_rate"], a=35768, # 15570 # 35768 with inflation 2% 1981 till 2023 b=0.558, )
And the pump_station_cost_kw function is:
def pump_station_cost_kw(power_kw, usd_to_eur, a=35768, b=0.558):
Calculate pump station investment cost from installed power in kW. Parameters: ----------- power_kw : float or array Installed pump power in kW. a : float Cost factor in Eur/HP (default 35768). Source: Inflation a2023=15570(1.02)**42≈35,768 USD/HP in https://hypat.de/hypat-wAssets/docs/new/publikationen/HYPAT_WP_Water-Supply-for-Electrolysis-Plants.pdf). b : float Scaling exponent (default 0.558) Source: 1+b = 1-0.442 in https://hypat.de/hypat-wAssets/docs/new/publikationen/HYPAT_WP_Water-Supply-for-Electrolysis-Plants.pdf). usd_to_eur : float Conversion rate from USD to EUR . Returns: -------- cost_eur : float or array Pump station cost in million EUR. # Convert kW to HP power_hp = power_kw / 0.7457 # Cost formula in USD cost_usd = a * (power_hp ** b) # Convert to EUR cost_eur = cost_usd * usd_to_eur # Return cost in million EUR return cost_eur / 1e6
So technology (1981) and currency year (2023)
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Thanks @Eddy-JV ! We need to get this information somehow into the comment/description, such that users can understand the data provenance
| water booster pump,FOM,2023,2,%/year,2023,"HYPAT_WP_Water-Supply-for-Electrolysis-Plants, https://hypat.de/hypat-wAssets/docs/new/publikationen/HYPAT_WP_Water-Supply-for-Electrolysis-Plants.pdf", | ||
| water booster pump,lifetime,2023,30,years,2023,"HYPAT_WP_Water-Supply-for-Electrolysis-Plants, https://hypat.de/hypat-wAssets/docs/new/publikationen/HYPAT_WP_Water-Supply-for-Electrolysis-Plants.pdf", |
| water booster pump,investment,2023,4775,EUR/kW,2023,"Calculated based on HYPAT_WP_Water-Supply-for-Electrolysis-Plants, https://hypat.de/hypat-wAssets/docs/new/publikationen/HYPAT_WP_Water-Supply-for-Electrolysis-Plants.pdf",Cost of water booster pump per horsepower | ||
| water booster pump,FOM,2023,2,%/year,2023,"HYPAT_WP_Water-Supply-for-Electrolysis-Plants, https://hypat.de/hypat-wAssets/docs/new/publikationen/HYPAT_WP_Water-Supply-for-Electrolysis-Plants.pdf", | ||
| water booster pump,lifetime,2023,30,years,2023,"HYPAT_WP_Water-Supply-for-Electrolysis-Plants, https://hypat.de/hypat-wAssets/docs/new/publikationen/HYPAT_WP_Water-Supply-for-Electrolysis-Plants.pdf", | ||
| water booster pump,efficiency,2023,0.765,per unit,2023,"HYPAT_WP_Water-Supply-for-Electrolysis-Plants, https://hypat.de/hypat-wAssets/docs/new/publikationen/HYPAT_WP_Water-Supply-for-Electrolysis-Plants.pdf", No newline at end of file |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Efficiency is not clear for this technology.
Minimum: Add to the details what the efficiency unit is
Ideally: Change the unit to something more clear, maybe m3 water per kWh or something?
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Hi @euronion . The efficiency here is taken from the same source by multiplying the motor efficiency wiith the pump efficiency: 0.85 x 0.9=0.765
I guess we can consider the unit to be m3 water per kWh
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Please document this in the further description. Others can't be asked to dig into this PR to find out the unit and meaning behind an entry.
Co-authored-by: Johannes HAMPP <42553970+euronion@users.noreply.github.com>
Closes # (if applicable).
Changes proposed in this Pull Request
Adding costs for HDPE water pipelines and pumps -> needed for integration of desalination and water management in pypsa-earth
Checklist
doc.environment.yaml(if applicable).doc/release_notes.rstof the upcoming release is included.